News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by sokoloff on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @05:13PM (#13647729)
Here's the key line in the article:

> Under European labor laws, permanent workers are usually more difficult to lay off and require more costly benefit packages, making temporary contracts appealing for all manner of industries, from low-wage warehouse workers to professional white-collar jobs.

Make it extremely costly for an employer to exit a permanent contract and employers are less willing to enter those contracts. Shouldn't be terribly surprising.

Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by wyager on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @05:45PM (#13648009)
This is a very common theme with labor laws. Most people are very, very bad at predicting second- or higher- order effects of a regulation. If the market encourages some behavior one doesn't like (like firing people), it may be the case that one is simply too myopic to comprehend whatever large-scale stochastic optimization the market is doing, and what's going to give when one stops that optimization from happening.

As a result, many (most?) well-meaning market restrictions end up hurting more than they help, often in indirect and difficult to quantify ways spread out over thousands of different interactions. This (friction introduced by the inability to fire people who should be fired) is actually one of the easier examples to point to.

Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by vyodaiken on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @05:50PM (#13648052)
People are bad at predicting effects. Absence of market regulations can also have bad effects.
Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by monk_e_boy on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @06:22PM (#13648268)
Ir reminds me of all the weird policies regarding programmer pay vs performance that I've seen.

Get a bonus for most bugs fixed? Lots of bugs produced, logged and fixed.

Get a bonus for bug free code? Very little code produced.

I do think for economics a more detailed simulation is needed in which we can try different laws before they passed.

Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by sokoloff on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @07:39PM (#13648726)
The problem with simulation for testing is that it requires creativity. Creativity of a distributed set of actors, each acting in their own (perceived) self-interest and trying to find exploits.

If you program a simulation with the same type of thinking used to draft the law, assuming that people will employ and comply with the law "as intended", you're liable to fall prey to an exploit that you weren't creative enough to think about, else you'd have (possibly) addressed it in the law.

Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by tostitos1979 on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @05:41PM (#13647966)
I've met quite a few grad student interns from Europe. Was very surprised when they told me. Quite an unintended consequence of a well-meaning policy.
Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by chrisseaton on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @06:29PM (#13648322)
I don't quite get what you mean. Surely a temporary contract is ideal for a grad student intern, who doesn't have time to enter full-time employment?
Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by candiodari on Wednesday February 15, 2017 @07:03AM (#13651397)
These are day-to-day contracts. I don't think you understand how temporary they are.

As for flexibility of hours on interim contracts, it's nonexistent, because employers don't want to give that. They'll hire whoever just complies with their hours and usually not even allow for swaps.

I've even been on the other side of this. Allowing hour swaps leads to first the impression of preferential treatment, then actual preferential treatment (because "he's doing it"), then fights, then a total disaster.

Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by tostitos1979 on Wednesday February 15, 2017 @01:35PM (#13654218)
The students were complaining that they saw very little permanent, full-time employment opportunities in their countries.
Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by literallycancer on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @05:56PM (#13648084)
In some places it's actually illegal to intentionally skirt the labor laws by using temporary contractors for jobs that are not of temporary nature (seasonal agriculture workers ok, cashiers not ok), but yeah, it's not enforced that much.
Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by ptaipale on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @06:20PM (#13648259)
And trying to enforce it won't really help. It'll just drive away even those temp jobs, if the employers cannot find legal ways to go around requirements.

The fundamental problem is that employment law tries to treat the employer as a nasty exploiter, not as a provider of something good to those to whom it pays salary. The law often starts from confrontation and zero-sum game, not from having shared goals and interests.

Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by Broken_Hippo on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @06:39PM (#13648380)
The biggest reason for this is that some employers are nasty exploiters. I'd like to make-believe that everyone treats each other well, but it just isn't so. The laws aren't designed to accuse everyone, but to protect future workers from suffering a similar fate.

So you wind up getting laws designed so that employers need to be fair when firing, allowing folks time off after pregnancy (including men), allowing folks to stay home when they are sick, and making sure folks can try to correct their ways before getting fired.

And contrary to your belief, enforcement of laws seems to happen here (norway). Temp agencies seem to be much more used than they were in the US.. and weirdly less predatory to the worker. It still sucks only having a temp job, but that's how a lot of folks get started working here.

Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by ptaipale on Wednesday February 15, 2017 @02:59AM (#13650462)
Of course some employers are nasty exploiters.

However, treating all employers as nasty exploiters then means that more of them will have to act such. A better recourse would be to ensure the labour market works, so that the nasty exploiters lose employees and have to start behave themselves.

Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by maverick_iceman on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @10:50PM (#13649543)
Sure some (I'd grant even a majority) employers are nasty exploiters. But let the employees handle them. They are adults, they can make their own decisions. I don't see why the government has to play mommy.
Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by Broken_Hippo on Wednesday February 15, 2017 @06:33AM (#13651269)
How do you expect they do that? Do you have example where it works out for the people being treated badly now? Would a lawsuit work if there aren't laws to protect you? What sort of decision is it when you have to stay home with your sick child while knowing you could lose your job or have your hours cut because of it? Is there recourse when an employer reports you were fired, even though you put in your notice?

There aren't remedies for these folks in the states Now. If all people had that power, they'd be more likely to use it. Unfortunately, you have to have a bit of privilege to pull it off when there aren't laws to protect you (and sometimes when there are).

Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by candiodari on Wednesday February 15, 2017 @07:05AM (#13651405)
You limit the supply of labor by having strong support for the jobless.

And while I realize that this is controversial, but in order for this to work 2 other conditions are necessary:

1) limit immigration

2) throw the book at any employer caught employing illegal immigrants (because they're not doing it to help the illegal immigrants)

Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by literallycancer on Wednesday February 15, 2017 @01:40PM (#13654282)
The employees handled them. They handled them by voting in a government that passed the labor regulation that forbids employers from firing people because they feel like it.

Sans the (many) inefficiencies, the government is basically an expression of the collective will.

Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by aanm1988 on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @07:05PM (#13648546)
Employers need employees. They won't go out of business rather than just hiring some full time people, unless the numbers say they have to.

> The fundamental problem is that employment law tries to treat the employer as a nasty exploiter

Because they are, almost inevitably, if left unchecked.

Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by gozur88 on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @08:08PM (#13648892)
Employers do need employees, but anything that raises the cost of employing someone is going to result in more outsourcing and more automation.
Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by ptaipale on Wednesday February 15, 2017 @03:01AM (#13650472)
Or simply deadweight loss: the work is not done, the business does not exist, the social welfare function is lost.
Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by candiodari on Wednesday February 15, 2017 @07:08AM (#13651426)
Sure but what would this actually apply to ? I get that deliveroo and maybe uber would be out of business, but for instance supermarkets wouldn't be.

Is slightly more convenience for the rich (if you use uber and deliveroo, that means you) worth allowing exploitation of the poor ? If so, how much ?

Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by sokoloff on Wednesday February 15, 2017 @08:14AM (#13651732)
Way more people use Uber than just "the rich".

Do only "the rich" use taxicabs? Uber is generally cheaper than a cab, so if middle class uses cabs (and overwhelmingly has smart phones), why wouldn't they also use Uber?

Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by gozur88 on Wednesday February 15, 2017 @12:50PM (#13653849)
Sometimes it's about bringing comfort and convenience to people who aren't rich. Rich people don't need Uber.

Also, poor people generally would rather be "exploited" and employed than on the dole.

Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by literallycancer on Wednesday February 15, 2017 @01:44PM (#13654304)
But maybe they like being employed with favorable regulations even better?
Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by ptaipale on Wednesday February 15, 2017 @02:04PM (#13654488)
Sure, but perfect is the enemy of good.
Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by andmarios on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @07:00PM (#13648513)
I disagree with your conclusion because the timeline is different; first there was the labor law which was won via tough fights from the working class and then came the lobbyists, the crooked politicians, the neoliberals etc and essentially took down the law by allowing temporary workers.

Thus I would go with something like make it extremely easy for the employer to get employees without any kind of obligation and the employer will be less willing to choose any type of contract that respects the employee. As we so often hear, the responsibility of the CEO is to the shareholders (thus not to the employees).

Re:Feeling ‘Pressure All the Time’ on Europe’s Treadmill of ... by sokoloff on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @07:40PM (#13648735)
IMO, the CEO is responsible to at least three sets of stakeholders generally: customers, investors, and employees.

The order in which or degree to which the CEO considers each constituency when making decisions might vary by the decision, but I generally favor them in the order listed above (even as I am an employee). If you don't serve your customers well, nothing else matters...

As for the law being worked arond, that was bound to happen; I think anytime you unduly restrict one side, that side will seek loopholes or exploits or withdraw from engaging. In this case, hiring temporary workers, engaging other companies under contract, automating the function (entirely or partially), moving that function to another geography, or doing without happens.

I'm in the process of opening another software development location in Europe. In studying where to locate, it was surprising to me how varied labor law was across various locales, and while any such decision is obviously multi-dimensional, labor law was a significant driver in the final location selected. (Several finalist locations were all workable; one of the locations had a much more balanced set of labor laws and local practices.) To inhabitants and prospective employees in the locations not selected, that looks identical to jobs moving away from their locale to another, more balanced, locale in large part due to local labor law.