The sad part is that the DE boys keep thinking that more eyecandy and bling will bring in the users and thus the third party software (apps? bah!) devs.
But as JWZ put it, Gnome (and most of the XDG related stuff) is beset with CADT. They fail to see that the one thing that has kept Windows where it is right now is that some company can still run their bespoke business code that was written back in the Windows 3.11 days.
Damn it, they can't even manage to do minor updates to glib and related without introducing subtle breakages.
And no, Flatpak and related is not a fix. That will just bring the specter of DLL hell to Linux.
Maybe you and I just aren't the target demographic (and the source demographic I guess) any more? Back in the day from what I remember, the Linux Desktop was trying to copy Windows because that's what people knew. Certainly worldwide there were a lot more OSS devs that started using computers with a copy of Windows, than there were devs that started computing on one of the research systems in MIT. Windows was what people knew, Windows was what they grew up with, Windows was what they wanted to recreate. Now Macs are the choice du jour among the young crowd. While you can objectively say that there has been a drop in features and an uptick in useless(?) bling, I'm not sure it's the result of an actual shift in the base paradigm.
> Maybe you and I just aren't the target demographic (and the source demographic I guess) any more?
I wouldn't expect them to throw out their userbase just for fun?
I suspect ux experts with good intentions, having read the latest studies on usability which told everyone including Microsoft (back before Windows 8) that everything should be optimized for touch and for users who have no clue about the desktop.
They really want to create an awesome desktop for everyone but forget that for a number of their current users their current desktop is more or less exactly what they want.
KDE hits a middle ground by providing (again IMO) sensible defaults and infinte possibilities for styling and tweaking.
Edit: weirdly enough one distro I like is Elementary, who managed to copy the looks of Mac OSX without bringing along stuff like the (IMO) broken alt-tab. I'd still like if they could give me my menus back but at least I find that DE tolerable compared to Unity.
Thanks for explaining!
When Ubuntu shipped KDE5, normal usability stuff broke horribly again. Nowadays I have two kids and a job managing a large IT organisation. I simply can't defend spending the time any more. So I switched to xfce for the time being. Of that breaks the UI in any comparable way, I give in to the hordes that keep ridiculing me for not using a Mac. :(
What do yo mean by "normal usability stuff broke horribly again"?
I'm using Neon now and it is one of the least annoying distros and DEs I have ever worked with.
Also I was bit by the bug that somebody else mentioned here: the panels would disappear with sweet reliability. If I remember correctly, this was a bug that would hide the existing dock. So if you simpy recreated it, you'd have two running side by side, and so on.
There was more but I don't remember specifics. The screen issues were enough to be a big practical problem for me.
Edit: speeling
I don't use docking and rarely use multiple monitors so that might explain a bit of the difference in experience.
Except the music player! It's pretty broken on a hidpi screen.
I would however expect it to work well on my 5 year old laptop.
Agree.
I sense I am getting old and grumpy but there is something to learn here: there seems to be an increasing number of people, even in open source, who just want stuff to work.
I just want Ubuntu, dropline gnome, updated drivers, backed by a commercial vendor that I can pay a reasonable amount to to make sure they never let designers, ux people, product managers etc experiment with my desktop. Polishing it like Ubuntu originally did was totally ok though.
I don't want "spatial navigation" in Gnome. I don't want to have to think application or document" when I hit alt-tab, or having to wait for a (IMO, I know some people love this feature, but bear with my rant here) retarded alt-tab to understand that I want to switch to a document under the app I have switched to, then wait again for it to slide out nicely.
No! I want alt tab to switch through my last used windows. If it looks really nice, bonus.
I want my drivers to work. Etc.
And most of all: I don't want Linux to copy Mac! If I want a Mac I can get my boss to get me one!