News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Questions the FBI Uses to Determine If Someone Is a Likel... by noobermin on Monday February 13, 2017 @06:00PM (#13639644)
No, but take a gander at 21). Does using encryption, "password-protected websites", IP Anonymization make me a terrorist? I think that describes a significant fraction of people here.

Sure, that should be taken in context to the rest of the questions, but should that even be a flag? Should we regularly detain and question pentesters now if they have a middle-eastern background?

Re:Questions the FBI Uses to Determine If Someone Is a Likel... by darawk on Monday February 13, 2017 @06:08PM (#13639712)
No, but that isn't the only question on the list. Encryption combined with fundamentalism, tactical training, and a keen interest in prior attacks is definitely a red flag in my book. And the use of encryption/privacy software definitely strengthens that case.
Re:Questions the FBI Uses to Determine If Someone Is a Likel... by lettergram on Monday February 13, 2017 @06:30PM (#13639877)
Perhaps you are scared by fundamenralism. So you get tactical training, use encryption because you hate "big-brother", and anonymize your IP... Then because of your fear you research prior attacks.

I'm going to argue that's at least a tens of thousands of people if not many more. A lot of apps are implementing encryption (tens of millions of users), millions of Americans have tactical training, plus most Americans are interested in attacks.

Seems like this list doesn't really narrow down the suspect pool to meaningful numbers. More like, it makes it seem like people made this list to seem like they were doing something.

Re:Questions the FBI Uses to Determine If Someone Is a Likel... by darawk on Monday February 13, 2017 @06:42PM (#13639958)
I'm not saying that this is a perfect filter that has no false positives. No one is saying that. But if you were to give me profiles of every American citizen and ask me to find the terrorists - it's exactly where i'd start.
Re:Questions the FBI Uses to Determine If Someone Is a Likel... by noobermin on Monday February 13, 2017 @09:59PM (#13640814)
See my reply to another comment. I concede that Encryption in tandem with the other criteria is possibly something to take into account, but it certainly should not be in the same category of things like "expressing desire to travel overseas to engage in violence." On reading the first page, it looks the questionnaire answers are weighed, but I certainly hope that "wanting violence" isn't anywhere near the same weight as "encrypts his shit."
Re:Questions the FBI Uses to Determine If Someone Is a Likel... by darawk on Monday February 13, 2017 @10:14PM (#13640878)
I imagine it's not a weighting system per se. I don't know any more than you, so all I can say really is that if I were designing it, encryption would be considered a major red flag one someone who already had the other characteristics.

That is, if someone encrypts, that means nothing. But if you are comparing two fundamentalists predisposed to violence, and one of them uses crypto and privacy software and the other doesn't - I would lean heavily towards investigating the crypto guy. He's likely planning something.

I guess what i'm saying is that I think the interaction of a feature like crypto should be nonlinear with certain other features.

Re:Questions the FBI Uses to Determine If Someone Is a Likel... by benchaney on Monday February 13, 2017 @06:17PM (#13639780)
Fundamentalism, tactical training and a keep interest in prior attacks is a red flag on its own. I don't think that encryption adds anything.
Re:Questions the FBI Uses to Determine If Someone Is a Likel... by ucaetano on Monday February 13, 2017 @06:23PM (#13639822)
Someone like that who suddenly starts using encryption is a major red flag. Fundamentalism, tactical training and a keep interest in prior attacks aren't enough to single out someone who's preparing an attack, but someone like that who went off the grid, started using encryption and just maxed out his credit card needs far more attention than someone spreading have from their basement.
Re:Questions the FBI Uses to Determine If Someone Is a Likel... by benchaney on Monday February 13, 2017 @06:36PM (#13639910)
Again, maxing credit cards and going to the grid are red flags, but I still don't see what encryption adds.
Re:Questions the FBI Uses to Determine If Someone Is a Likel... by darawk on Monday February 13, 2017 @06:44PM (#13639964)
Encryption suggests active planning. Using encryption is what you do when you are actively trying to hide your activity. The others are indicators of susceptible traits - but encryption suggests imminence and active involvement. If you have gone beyond just developing radical beliefs and start actually planning an attack, that's when you're likely to start using encryption and taking operational security seriously.
Re:Questions the FBI Uses to Determine If Someone Is a Likel... by ucaetano on Monday February 13, 2017 @07:45PM (#13640282)
Look at the actual wording:

Has the subject engaged in or discussed tradecraft to hide their online activities contextually different from previous activity?

The relevant part isn't the encryption, but the context. If you have two email accounts, one for general usage, unencrypted, and one encrypted that you rarely use, but suddenly see a spike in usage, that's a red flag.

It isn't if you use encryption, but how you use it.

Re:Questions the FBI Uses to Determine If Someone Is a Likel... by Godel_unicode on Monday February 13, 2017 @06:03PM (#13639673)
That's hardly the only question like that. Many things on this list would, if taken in isolation, not be indicative of terrorist leanings. I'm assuming that's why there are many questions on this list.
Re:Questions the FBI Uses to Determine If Someone Is a Likel... by noobermin on Monday February 13, 2017 @06:08PM (#13639713)
Alright, I was about to delete my comment above when I saw a reply to another comment which had similar sentiment to mine. I guess what we need then is what weight they assign to each of these. That "using encryption" is on the same level as a listing on "express[ing] a desire to travel overseas to engage violence"[0] doesn't inspire my confidence. It makes me think that this questionnaire won't be as effective.

[0] according to the leaked document. If they weights are assigned by some other rubric in another document not leaked or part of this article at least, then I guess I am wrong.

Re:Questions the FBI Uses to Determine If Someone Is a Likel... by ucaetano on Monday February 13, 2017 @07:55PM (#13640329)
But the document doesn't talk about "using encryption", it says: Has the subject engaged in or discussed tradecraft to hide their online activities contextually different from previous activity?
Re:Questions the FBI Uses to Determine If Someone Is a Likel... by noobermin on Monday February 13, 2017 @09:54PM (#13640799)
After the "check all that apply" Encryption is listed on the next line.