Re:Areas near Sacramento evacuated as Oroville spillway coll...
by lisper on Sunday February 12, 2017 @11:25PM
(#13633123)
No, the emergency spillway is part of the dam. Failure of the spillway could lead to failure of the entire dam. It's not likely, but it's possible. Once large quantities of water start going where they weren't designed to go, all bets are off.
Re:Areas near Sacramento evacuated as Oroville spillway coll...
by Tloewald on Monday February 13, 2017 @02:42AM
(#13633731)
You should look at the dam from maps or satellite. The spillway is off to the side, away from the dam (clearly, by design), and the emergency spillway is on the far side of the main spillway from the dam, so while the spillway failing would be terrible it should not damage the dam itself.
Re:Areas near Sacramento evacuated as Oroville spillway coll...
by lisper on Monday February 13, 2017 @09:33AM
(#13635438)
Looks like you're right. I read somewhere that the spillway was part of the dam structure, but now I can't find that reference any more, so I guess I must have misread it.
However, my original comment was still substantially correct. See http://www.sacbee.com/news/local/article132356269.html
"It’s not going to be the (main) embankment failure, but it’s a failure. If it does happen, there’s nothing saying that the ground is going to stay where it is. That force of water will start tearing that hill apart, and it could eat back into the reservoir and drain the reservoir.
Re:Areas near Sacramento evacuated as Oroville spillway coll...
by djcapelis on Sunday February 12, 2017 @11:53PM
(#13633207)
It certainly could, but they are literally separate structures, as repeated stated by the actual engineers who maintain the dam.
Re:Areas near Sacramento evacuated as Oroville spillway coll...
by jcranmer on Monday February 13, 2017 @01:44AM
(#13633549)
The hillside underneath the overflow spillway is literally washing away. You can see downhill portions of the spillway where the waters ate away 10, 20 feet of vertical elevation. If that erosion backs all the way up to the reservoir itself, then the lining could fail (much as the main spillway did). At that point, it doesn't matter if the dam is still standing, if there is a gash right next to it lowering the effective maximum water level by several feet.
I don't know enough about the geology of the area to know how likely it is to happen. But history does show that dams can go very quickly once erosion reaches the dam/reservoir, so alarm isn't exactly unwarranted.
Re:Areas near Sacramento evacuated as Oroville spillway coll...
by kobeya on Monday February 13, 2017 @04:42AM
(#13634167)
It'll hit bedrock.
There's definitely worries about the erosion on the main spillway moving back upstream towards the dam, but that is something folks are going to have to look at and consider over the remaining duration of the water season, unlikely to be a danger tonight.