News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:High-speed rail taking shape even as opponents seek to ki... by _red on Sunday February 12, 2017 @01:54PM (#13629861)
For short distances high-speed rail can be a good option, particularly in connecting neighboring cities (LA-SF, etc).

The problems with all these projects are cost: Simple back of envelope calculations show it to be (a) dubious, or (b) possibly criminal (ie. standard taxpayer ripoff to cronies).

$64B - do the quick math on that. Figure a 30 year return on investment earning 4% per year:

$2.2B payback per year + operating cost of what? So somewhere around $7M per day in revenues minimum?

How many riders per day and what is average ticket price to make $7M per day?

I think you will suddenly find there are cheaper, faster, better options.

Re:High-speed rail taking shape even as opponents seek to ki... by crazy2be on Sunday February 12, 2017 @10:52PM (#13632996)
Well, a flight from SFO to LAX is $70 if you book at least a couple weeks in advance. If you assume parity for the ticket price, you need to sell an average of 100,000 tickers/day. With 100 passengers per car and 10 cars per train, you would need 100 trains/day, full, in order to make the math work.

I agree that seems pretty dubious. Why on earth is infrastructure so expensive in the US?

Re:High-speed rail taking shape even as opponents seek to ki... by rhino369 on Monday February 13, 2017 @12:47PM (#13637191)
>Why on earth is infrastructure so expensive in the US?

Infrastructure always is, but in the USA it's worse than normal. Nobody is entirely sure why.

Re:High-speed rail taking shape even as opponents seek to ki... by briandear on Monday February 13, 2017 @03:20AM (#13633873)
Why is an apartment so expensive in SF? Why is an acre of land in Napa or Malibu so expensive?
Re:High-speed rail taking shape even as opponents seek to ki... by pzone on Sunday February 12, 2017 @09:05PM (#13632615)
It's less wasteful to spend $20 billion building a pointless wall on the Mexican border than the ~$40 billion in losses this rail is going to eat. I'm glad I'm not a California resident.