Re:How We Moved From Microsoft ASP.NET to Rails and NoSQL
by pbz on Wednesday May 19, 2010 @06:13PM
(#1362548)
So then why not just replace the database and keep the rest? Were you using Linq to SQL and hence tied to SQL Server? As far as VS I'm sure it would not have been a problem for you to get free versions. However, I suppose if you were to change the database portion, probably a sizable chunk of the application, you may as well replace the whole thing...
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:How We Moved From Microsoft ASP.NET to Rails and NoSQL
by billpaetzke on Wednesday May 19, 2010 @10:32PM
(#1363092)
If you're developing with .NET, you are best off using the whole Microsoft stack. The vertical consolidation and tight integration is the benefit you get for the high costs.
If you mix .NET code with significant OSS components (i.e. databases), you will incur a lot of extra setup work and hassle. There is less of a community and therefore you'll have to figure more stuff out on your own. If you're a .NET programmer for life, then this is great experience for you.
One of the traits of a good CTO is to access the community around a mix of technologies (i.e. C#/Sql Server, C#/MongoDb, or Ruby/MongoDb). If there's a good community around your technology stack, that'll streamline development a lot more. Things will just work. Many people will have already solved the problems you're bound to have.
Re:How We Moved From Microsoft ASP.NET to Rails and NoSQL
by robconery on Wednesday May 19, 2010 @07:13PM
(#1362703)
But why? My cost right now (aside from hardware, which is net even) is 0 - without the hoops. Also - the testing story is much better.
Re:How We Moved From Microsoft ASP.NET to Rails and NoSQL
by pbz on Wednesday May 19, 2010 @07:32PM
(#1362747)
Was the cost of rewriting that small? In my view it would only make sense if the cost of rewriting the app is insignificant. If you can do it in a week or two, sure... any more than that and I would start to question if it's worth it. I mean, you gotta make sure it brings in money first, right? :-)
Re:How We Moved From Microsoft ASP.NET to Rails and NoSQL
by robconery on Thursday May 20, 2010 @01:35AM
(#1363323)
Overall about 2 weeks total. I took my time and wrote it first in Sinatra, then scrapped and went to Rails - 2 weeks :)