Re:Oracle refuses to accept pro-Google “fair use” verdict in...
by Spivak on Saturday February 11, 2017 @03:31PM
(#13624639)
I mean the courts aren't exactly robotic in this sense. It has to be a creative work, for the same reason you couldn't try to copyright a trivial sentence you wouldn't get copyright protection on a method description that adds two numbers. Also, it's the whole work that's copyrighted, not its individual parts. It's not that Google just borrowed a few method signatures, it's that they took all of them along with their relationships and meanings.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Oracle refuses to accept pro-Google “fair use” verdict in...
by AsyncAwait on Saturday February 11, 2017 @03:39PM
(#13624678)
You aren't wrong, but the fear is that copyright trolls would immediatelly take massive advantage of this new opportunity as well as that it could have a chilling effects on open-source projects.
Even if eventually found to be in the right, a random guy with a GitHub repo is not going to have the resources/will to effectively defend himself.