News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:This is the best explanation of gerrymandering you will e... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday February 11, 2017 @04:19AM (#13621877)
> Imagine you have 100 single-winner districts that are each roughly 50/50 Dem/GOP, with the slight edge breaking 50/50, so that your legislature has 50 reps from each party.

Imagine you have 100 single-winner districts with range voting so that there aren't two parties, or any strong parties at all.

Then the platform needed to win a district is district-specific, because a candidate with a district-specific platform beats any party's general platform in that district. Even if the winning candidate is a member of a party, the candidate still has to do what the district wants over what the party wants or they'll lose the seat.

The winning candidate in single-district range voting is literally the one that gets the highest average rating within the district, so it optimizes for no surplus at all.

If there was any then an independent candidate could show up with a platform that captures it by aligning more closely with the district and thereby win the seat.

The only way to do better than that is to do the same thing but with smaller districts, at the cost of having more members of the legislature (and in the limit it becomes direct democracy).

> No. Most PR systems still have districts.

I don't mean there are no districts, I mean that in PR instead of being stuck with a district that might not represent you in some ways, you're stuck with a party that might not represent you in some ways.

And PR STV doesn't fix that. Anything that increases the number of constituents per representative inherently can't, because that is what causes the problem to begin with. Diluting each vote by 20 times but giving each constituent 20 times as many representatives doesn't cancel out.

If a state upstream from your district is dumping poison in the river, no candidate could win that district without addressing it. But with any kind of PR, it's possible for every representative to ignore it because the affected voters split between twenty representatives, none of which need 1/20th of their votes enough to address the problem.

And RRV looks like it would create a lot of strange incentives, like giving a lower score to candidates you strongly like if you think they're likely to win regardless, except that if everyone thinks that way then that candidate loses.

There are no comments on this comment yet.