News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Obama's lost army by Jerry2 on Saturday February 11, 2017 @12:52AM (#13621263)
Obama's "Hope and Change" slogan was all smoke and mirrors and was pretty much meaningless because he never fully explained what those meant to him. In an absence of a concrete definition, people just assumed that 'change' was whatever their pet cause was and Obama's team never corrected anyone. It was truly a stroke of genius.

Unfortunately, he had no chance of making any meaningful change when Wall Street picked his whole cabinet for him [0]. It was just impossible to make changes that the society wanted because he was owned by the people who didn't want any change.

[0] https://newrepublic.com/article/137798/important-wikileaks-r...

Re:Obama's lost army by jordanb on Saturday February 11, 2017 @02:14AM (#13621550)
Obama had a lot of specifics during his campaign in 2008 and I think he really believed in some of them. And he accomplished some of them. For instance, he did pass a heavily watered down healthcare law, and a heavily watered down financial regulation law. He also implemented a way-too-small stimulus.

He did promise to renegotiate NAFTA though, walked it back almost immediately and then gave us the TPP instead. During his first overseas trip to London he was asked if the Washington Consensus was dead. He dodged the question.

I think he was fundamentally a reactionary in the areas that really matter, and in the areas where people really want hope and change. He appointed Timothy Geithner and Eric Holder and they made sure nobody on Wall Street was ever held accountable.

At one point he told Wall Street executives that he was the only thing between them and the pitchforks. Well he's gone now, planning to follow Bill Clinton onto the lecture circuit no doubt. And the pitchforks have gotten sharper than ever because fundamentally, where it really counts, nothing has gotten better since 2008.

Re:Obama's lost army by rtpg on Saturday February 11, 2017 @02:44AM (#13621625)
Only those who aren't paying attention can seriously claim nothing has gotten better wrt Wall Street regulation. It's in the same court as "both parties are the same" memes from intellectual laziness.

The Consumer Finance Protection Bureau has helped make sure that banks can't outright lie about their conflicts of interests. Various Dodd-Frank stuff has helped along that.

Billion-dollar fines for 2008's behaviors have meant that banks are losing money. And as an end result, banks are taking the rules more seriously! Hiring "boring" CEOs to help reign in the craziness. Anyone paying attention can see that the financial industry has been preparing itself for a new normal of "not crazily dishonest" (Obviously Trump is changing that posture a bit).

It's possible to believe that not enough was done, without saying they're the same.

Now... pitchfork sharpness is more connected to impressions than fact. Maybe that's the impression of people. But it's not the reality.

PS: who would you rather want in any regulatory body? someone who's worked in the industry before, and understands the issues at stake? Or someone who doesn't understand anything about the industry?

Hiring regulators from Wall Street (to a lower paying job) isn't sign of "the power of the lobbies". It's like saying that hiring a former programmer to be a CTO is a conflict of interest. The objective isn't punishment, it's making sure that the financial industry serves its purpose to society properly.

Re:Obama's lost army by ricw on Saturday February 11, 2017 @01:40AM (#13621439)
Having read obamas book audacity of hope (highly recommended), I strongly disagree. I presume that what he describes in his book was what he was referring to as change: ending bi-partisanship in Washington and constructively making things better by bridging the gap between republicans and democrats.

In the end, it seems he was more gridlocked then any of the prior presidents in recent memory and had to resort to more executive orders than previous president. Though potus 45 seems to be following his example in that regard..

Re:Obama's lost army by btilly on Saturday February 11, 2017 @01:51AM (#13621475)
...had to resort to more executive orders than previous president.

Sorry, you've swallowed false propaganda there. Look at the numbers at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_federal_... and compare.

The last President to issue fewer executive orders was George Bush Sr. To find a President with fewer executive orders per year, you have to go all of the way back to Grover Cleveland. That was in the 1800s.

This said, Trump is indeed on pace to average more executive orders than has been seen in the last 60 years.

Re:Obama's lost army by fosco on Monday February 13, 2017 @10:09AM (#13635757)
Here is a website that also breaks down per-term for ease of viewing/understanding.

http://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/data/orders.php

Re:Obama's lost army by aaron-lebo on Saturday February 11, 2017 @01:49AM (#13621469)
It's been said that Obama was a better campaigner than a politician (not to say he was a bad politician), and I think that holds up decently well. Keep in mind the book you cite is partially a campaign/marketing piece.

I mean the Democrats had control of government prior to 2010 and the ACA was still a compromise with lots of infighting between Democrats. Obama of course didn't help the divide by making pointed insults (clinging to their guns and religion). I don't have an article on hand, but even Democrats criticized Obama for having trouble forming cross-party friendships in a way someone like Bill Clinton did not.

He may have had the best intentions, but his difficulties were a little bit of obstructionism and a little bit of his own personality traits.

edit:

This is the kind of cross-party criticism that Obama got:

https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2014/08/a-brief...

http://www.cnn.com/2012/09/04/opinion/takiff-obama-fatherhoo...

https://www.nytimes.com/2014/08/19/us/aloof-obama-is-frustra...

Re:Obama's lost army by rdtsc on Saturday February 11, 2017 @02:15AM (#13621553)
> Obama was a better campaigner than a politician

He was an excellent campaigner. He even won "Marketer of the Year" award http://adage.com/article/moy-2008/obama-wins-ad-age-s-market... that usually goes to Apple, Coke, Nike and so on.

I would say vis-a-vis the Hope and Change enthusiasm and excitement a lot of people (myself included) were left with a "meh..." kind of feeling.

> This is the kind of cross-party criticism that Obama got...

More interestingly is to think what has he done for the Black community? Are inner cities a lot safer, are more jobs and housing available, more opportunities? These are people that pretty much voted as a block for him.

Then the whole Nobel Peace Prize thing, and just last year he dropped over 20k bombs on various countries around the world. Syria, ISIS happened on his watch and it seems he wasn't able to do much about it. The whole "crossing the red line...". He did kill Osama, but is that enough for a counter-balance the other stuff, not really...

Re:Obama's lost army by dragonwriter on Saturday February 11, 2017 @02:19AM (#13621564)
> I don't have an article on hand, but even Democrats criticized Obama for having trouble forming cross-party friendships in a way someone like Bill Clinton did not.

Those Democrats are, in a word, idiots. Or, they are Clinton loyalists that assume their audience is composed of idiots.

(1) Bill Clinton had already been long in politics and established those cross-party relationships before the hyperpartisanship on the right which blossomed during his Presidency made that impractical.

(2) The ACA was a massive compromise because of the epic failure the last time Democrats tried to do healthcare reform—under Bill Clinton and led by Hillary Clinton—at a time when there was majority public support in public polling for national single payer, and the Clintons were not only unable to get their "cross party friendships" to pay off, but also unable to pass anything despite the Democratic majority they had. This left Democrats across the board scared and looking for compromises to get something on healthcare, which is why three Democrats (Clinton, Obama, and Edwards) went into the 2008 primary with nearly identical health care plans that were all very close to Romneycarr, which itself was virtually identical to what a number of insurers and Republicans proposed as a national alternative after the failure of Clinton's healthcare reform.

(3) Obama, with party control of Congress in his time in office following the same general pattern as Clinton's, achieved far more in terms of Democratic policy priorities than Clinton, and also didn't manage to get impeached by the House of Representatives. Clinton's cross-party friendships didn't pay any dividends.

If Obama is a better campaigner that "politician" (at least as far as the latter concerns effectively leveraging the office and personal relationships for legislative success), than that criticism is even more applicable to Clinton, who kept rolling over for the Right and getting nothing (or less) in return.

Re:Obama's lost army by rdtsc on Saturday February 11, 2017 @02:27AM (#13621586)
> under Bill Clinton and led by Hillary Clinton—at a time when there was majority public support in public polling for national single payer

Also a prime example of corruption and nepotism. Bill handled Hillary that task when he was in the White House. She was not qualified for it and botched it basically.

Re:Obama's lost army by Marazan on Saturday February 11, 2017 @02:48AM (#13621633)
Due to legal wranglings over the 2008 senate results and Dem senator illness the Dems 'controlled' government for about 75 days. Outside that time the Republicans simply fillibustered everything and the Dems didn't have the 60 votes necessary in the senate for Cloture.
Re:Obama's lost army by gozur88 on Saturday February 11, 2017 @02:44AM (#13621626)
> I don't have an article on hand, but even Democrats criticized Obama for having trouble forming cross-party friendships in a way someone like Bill Clinton did not.

When Obama came to office he made no attempt to form cross-party friendships. When a new president responds to criticisms with "I won", you know he's in for a rough ride.

The extent to which Obama made enemies, both domestically and internationally, when he didn't need to was astounding. When he was on top he made sure you didn't forget it, and people tend to look for ways to return the favor when you do that.

Re:Obama's lost army by kevbin on Saturday February 11, 2017 @02:48AM (#13621631)
Obama had trouble with intra-party relationships, as your third link points out:

> “You and Mitch work it out,” Mr. Obama said coolly, cutting off any discussion.

> Mr. Reid seethed quietly for the rest of the meeting, according to four separate accounts provided by people who spoke with him about it.

…

> But nearly six years into his term, with his popularity at the lowest of his presidency, Mr. Obama appears remarkably distant from his own party on Capitol Hill, with his long neglect of would-be allies catching up to him.

Great campaigner. Willfully bad politician.

Re:Obama's lost army by GuiA on Saturday February 11, 2017 @01:52AM (#13621480)
The main reason Bill Clinton had no trouble forming these cross party relationships is because he was white.
Re:Obama's lost army by aaron-lebo on Saturday February 11, 2017 @01:55AM (#13621490)
Bill Clinton is incredibly personable; I don't think that has anything to do with race.
Re:Obama's lost army by dragonwriter on Saturday February 11, 2017 @02:46AM (#13621628)
The main reason Bill Clinton had no trouble forming those relationship is because he was a conservative Democrat, leader of the conservative Democratic Leadership Council, an organization that consistently reinforced Republican economic policy messaging while undercutting the Democratic left and the party's relafionship with its traditional base (particular the working class) by advancing neoliberal policies that were barely distinguishable from contemporary Republican policies.

Being a white rural southerner probably helped, too.

Re:Obama's lost army by Aloha on Saturday February 11, 2017 @01:51AM (#13621474)
.. and by doing so POTUS 45 will likely end up restricting the power of the president to act via Executive Order - this will likely bring to a close the era of the Imperial Presidency that began with TR.
Re:Obama's lost army by gozur88 on Saturday February 11, 2017 @02:34AM (#13621601)
>In the end, it seems he was more gridlocked then any of the prior presidents in recent memory and had to resort to more executive orders than previous president.

I doubt that's true - I don't remember Bush having any less trouble getting things done domestically.

There's nothing nefarious about executive orders - the president is the chief executive, and he directs his subordinates in the same way a corporate CEO does with memos. EOs are just directions on policy implementation. And it's all written in sand, since the next president can arbitrarily cancel or modify EOs.

Re:Obama's lost army by ProxCoques on Saturday February 11, 2017 @05:06AM (#13621994)
I was working for a US company here in the UK when Obama was elected. What struck us (the UK employees) was how amazingly trusting the Americans were of the Obama "change" and "hope" line. There were people with Obama "hope" chocolate bars on their desks, wearing hats with "change" and all sorts. I asked one of them about this and to my surprise they gave me a long speech about how it was all going to be so different now in US politics. Here in the UK (well until Brexit happened anyway) I don't think anyone expects huge changes to happen through party politics at all.
Re:Obama's lost army by vacri on Saturday February 11, 2017 @03:43AM (#13621774)
Not an American, but sitting on the sidelines, it never seemed to me that hope & change were a 'choose your own adventure' slogan. It seemed more like 'let's bring positivity back into vogue' after a two-term presidency of terrorism, poorly-handled natural disasters, divisive rhetoric, security theatre, war that didn't work out, and more war that didn't work out.
Re:Obama's lost army by gozur88 on Saturday February 11, 2017 @02:26AM (#13621583)
Meh. There are only two ways to brand a campaign: "Change", and "Back to the Good Old Days". Obama's was just the penultimate successful iteration of the first.

He had a chance to make changes in his first two years, and he did - the ACA was a pretty big change.

Re:Obama's lost army by Aloha on Saturday February 11, 2017 @01:44AM (#13621454)
Arguably just like "Make America Great Again"

Slogans without specifics are just that, slogans.