News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pugs are anatomical disasters. Vets must speak out–even i... by 13of40 on Thursday February 09, 2017 @10:44AM (#13607674)
Suppose there was a breed of, say, monkey, that was popular as a household pet. They were considered to be quite clever and could be trained, over some years, to use a toilet, fetch things from the fridge, even manage primitive forms of communication. The only problem is that they're a genetic trainwreck. They've got a pronounced, gourd-like head with a snout so compact that it's common to have to surgically remove some of their teeth. They've got limited ability in their front legs that forces them to spend their entire life in an abnormal posture, resulting in a cornucopia of spinal and joint problems that cause many of them lifelong pain. On top of all this, all of their natural defenses (claws, canines, protective fur) have been bred out and disease traits bred in (myopia, hemophilia, diabetes, and so on). Now, knowing all of this, suppose your sister, who already has three of these things running around her house, calls up and gleefully announces that they're getting another one. What do you tell her?
Re:Pugs are anatomical disasters. Vets must speak out–even i... by openasocket on Thursday February 09, 2017 @11:25AM (#13608049)
I mean, I know you're being ironic, but that's really an inaccurate view of people. Sure, we have certain diseases, but we're hardly unique in that regard. We live decades longer than our closest relatives, even without medical intervention. In terms of natural defenses, we are an apex predator, and have been even in the hunter-gatherer days. Even ignoring the fact that we are the most intelligent species on the planet, we're also one of the greatest distance runners in the animal kingdom.
Re:Pugs are anatomical disasters. Vets must speak out–even i... by maxerickson on Thursday February 09, 2017 @10:48AM (#13607712)
Humans are apes not monkeys.

What if you sister called and said there was a safe, cheap and effective way to remove, say, the myopia from her spawn (in the case of dogs, stop inbreeding, in the case of humans, currently imaginary)? Would you tell her not to do it?

Re:Pugs are anatomical disasters. Vets must speak out–even i... by 13of40 on Thursday February 09, 2017 @11:13AM (#13607918)
I had some in-laws at one point who had a kid with cystic fibrosis, and they decided to roll the dice and have a second one. (Murphy's Law won that round.) I can't imagine convincing those people to get their $1200 purebred pug[1] neutered for the good of the species.

[1] https://www.reference.com/pets-animals/much-pugs-87fd8b209ca...

Re:Pugs are anatomical disasters. Vets must speak out–even i... by maxerickson on Thursday February 09, 2017 @11:19AM (#13607989)
I imagine the thing to do would be to sell healthy dogs for $1500 (make sure lots of people say they are worth $1500).
Re:Pugs are anatomical disasters. Vets must speak out–even i... by darod on Thursday February 09, 2017 @12:56PM (#13609102)
so their second kid had CF too?
Re:Pugs are anatomical disasters. Vets must speak out–even i... by steve_b on Thursday February 09, 2017 @11:20AM (#13608001)
Re:Pugs are anatomical disasters. Vets must speak out–even i... by mikebenfield on Thursday February 09, 2017 @11:50AM (#13608343)
That is a very long-winded and opinionated article just to make the point that "ape" is not a taxonomic term, and it's not used completely consistently.

In any case, please don't promote anti-science articles (this one begins by complaining about "those who accept and promote evolution").

Re:Pugs are anatomical disasters. Vets must speak out–even i... by mdemare on Thursday February 09, 2017 @12:01PM (#13608493)
The writer is a Professor of Anthropology. Don't jump to conclusions.
Re:Pugs are anatomical disasters. Vets must speak out–even i... by steve_b on Friday February 10, 2017 @09:11PM (#13620535)
sorry, i came across way too bluntly. i really should have noted how suprised i was the an expert thinks its a misconception to think of ourselves as apes.

in any case, i think the author is very much in favour of science.

Re:Pugs are anatomical disasters. Vets must speak out–even i... by mdemare on Thursday February 09, 2017 @11:56AM (#13608423)
Hmm. We're "Great Apes" (hominids), but not "Apes"? That seems to violate common sense, in my opinion.
Re:Pugs are anatomical disasters. Vets must speak out–even i... by adamnemecek on Thursday February 09, 2017 @10:49AM (#13607718)
I've had good success with telling people about how the industry works. These people probably like dogs (which is why they are getting them) and showing them that dogs suffer quite a bit due to their choices can be convincing.
Re:Pugs are anatomical disasters. Vets must speak out–even i... by throwaway729 on Thursday February 09, 2017 @11:12AM (#13607913)
I mean, incest is illegal in many places. One of the major justifications (although perhaps not the main driver) is birth defects. So.
Re:Pugs are anatomical disasters. Vets must speak out–even i... by refurb on Thursday February 09, 2017 @11:02AM (#13607824)
My response would be "Is it possible to get a version of this monkey without these problems? No? Then go ahead."
Re:Pugs are anatomical disasters. Vets must speak out–even i... by Declanomous on Thursday February 09, 2017 @10:49AM (#13607721)
https://xkcd.com/1650/

But comparing humans to dogs in that matter is kind of ridiculous. This is more like if your sister called and said "I just read about chinese foot binding, and I think it's a great idea so I'm going to do it to my children!" That's basically what people who only accept dogs who have debilitatingly short snouts, etc. are doing.

Re:Pugs are anatomical disasters. Vets must speak out–even i... by mulletbum on Thursday February 09, 2017 @11:10AM (#13607898)
I think your confusing breeding with tail docking.
Re:Pugs are anatomical disasters. Vets must speak out–even i... by Declanomous on Thursday February 09, 2017 @11:16AM (#13607965)
I'm really not. Foot binding is similarly debilitating to the squished snout. It wasn't possible to choose an example that was literally the same because human's don't breed themselves for deformities.

If anything, now that we can test, many people take steps to make sure their children don't end up with debilitating traits. Having back issues when you are 60 isn't even remotely in the same league as the back issues these dogs end up with.

Re:Pugs are anatomical disasters. Vets must speak out–even i... by 13of40 on Thursday February 09, 2017 @11:28AM (#13608078)
> humans don't breed themselves for deformities.

Except maybe intelligence, I fail to see how the traits we breed for could be considered anything but deformities if a baboon had them.

Re:Pugs are anatomical disasters. Vets must speak out–even i... by Asooka on Thursday February 09, 2017 @12:14PM (#13608639)
Right now the only thing people are selecting for is wanting to breed and ability to provide for one's family. Sometimes. A study of who fucks who would be really interesting, but kind of useless because what would you do with the information?
Re:Pugs are anatomical disasters. Vets must speak out–even i... by redblacktree on Thursday February 09, 2017 @01:39PM (#13609556)
That second part "ability to provide for one's family" means something though, doesn't it? Our societies aren't perfect, but "ability to provide for oneself/family" does generally mean that they have certain desirable traits.
Re:Pugs are anatomical disasters. Vets must speak out–even i... by zardo on Thursday February 09, 2017 @11:02AM (#13607821)
People aren't binding pug's snouts. They just grow into hideously deformed beasts all on their own like people do.
Re:Pugs are anatomical disasters. Vets must speak out–even i... by maxerickson on Thursday February 09, 2017 @11:16AM (#13607954)
The successive generations of pure breeding are pretty artificially imposed.
Re:Pugs are anatomical disasters. Vets must speak out–even i... by tptacek on Thursday February 09, 2017 @02:29PM (#13610049)
Probably nothing. Monkeys are a telling example: almost nobody cares for a monkey, so in the absence of some genetically compromised monkey bred for suitability as pets, there not only would be no pet monkeys, but also fewer monkeys overall, as humans edge monkeys out of their habitats more and more every year.
Re:Pugs are anatomical disasters. Vets must speak out–even i... by elthran on Thursday February 09, 2017 @10:48AM (#13607711)
Well, when the monkey gets older it can use tools to defend itself, as well as keep itself alive. However, I would perhaps suggest teaching it abstinence, sterlilisation if it has one of the particularly debilitating genetic diseases