Depends, is your option of water cooling an All-In-One-solution that have become popular in recent years? Their performance is on par or slightly better than a large heat sink + large low speed fan(s), but they're not generally quieter, as you still have fans for them, as well as a pump.
I considered those options when building mine too, and as I wans't too enthusiastic about assembling my own water cooling system, I went for a large air cooled heatsink instead (the D15). No risk of leakage or pump failure, and proven performance/low noise.
However, I wish to have a quiet system, and my brother have it and it sound louder than I wish. I don't plan on overcloking.
http://www.anandtech.com/show/5054/corsair-hydro-series-h60-...
The "Silver Arrow" is an air cooler from Thermalright that is pretty equivalent to a Noctua or a Phantek or be Quiet! etc.
In that review it beats the H60 in both temperature and noise. The H60 is more than twice as loud.
So yes, unless you assemble your own water cooling system, I'd say definitely go for a regular heatsink+fan.
I'm tempted in build a hackintosh:
https://www.tonymacx86.com/threads/hackintosh-cutting-edge-k...
- Intel i7 Kaby Lake - No decided on motherboard. The one that cause me less trouble (for hackintosh) is fine. - GTI 750ti (have) or buy a pascal nvidia. - NVMe drive if possible - 32 GB RAM. - Probably a Thermaltake CORE P3 case. Not decided.
I was thinking in use a Liquid Cooler but wonder if the Noctua could be better/less noise?