But I think under the talk of freemium, the important questions get lost. Freemium - it's so easy, you give part of it away for free, and part you charge for. Right?
But what do you give for free? What do you charge for? How do you convince people to pay?
Those questions typically go completely unaddressed because of the assumption that money will, magically, appear somehow, with enough viral growth.
People treat the free part of freemium as if you can just slap it on like Sriracha sauce, and improve everything. That's simply not how it works.
Freckle has an extremely limited free plan and we sort of hide it. It is freemium but it is so limited it irritates some people.
But, based on the way other SaaS entrepreneurs choke on their coffee and go "Monthly?!" when I tell them how much we earn per 1000 accounts (total), that extremely limited, fairly hidden account works extremely well for us. :)
And, for the record, I believe the best free-mium strategy is to give away related content, not the thing itself. Give away the occasional cheese stick or cup of cocoa -- not the milk, and not timeshare access to the cow.
Could you elaborate on that? What's the use of your free account, if nobody uses it anyway?
It's like clipping coupons: you segment your audience by price sensitivity by making the cheap people (poorer leads) work for their discounts.
You've made this point in your comments, but offering a significant amount of content or software for free can be considered advertising for your paid product, and is practically essential for survival on the web anyway. Paywalls are last century; people want to be handed things now, and if you hand them things and give some slight nudges toward a premium account for extra features or whatever, that works fine, they just don't want to expect to be told anymore "$30 before you get to play". And honestly that's never been a good strategy, and it's even worse online, because it stops word-of-mouth, it stops search engines or other interested parties from indexing or trying your product, and just generally greatly reduces visibility.
Freemium is the way to go. There is no shame in charging for a good product, but keeping things under lock and key is not ideal either. You want to provide maximal "viral" potential, which is accomplished by making the bulk of the product freely available and accessible, and you also want to make sure you get paid in a good number of cases, which is accomplished by operating your free product correctly.