Only, clients give you money that you can use in any way you see fit: Grow your business, buy a West Coast Freeride bike, save it for a rainy day.
VCs put money in your business and then take your business for themselves and decide how to spend their money. It was never yours and never will be. If you wind up getting a big, big payday, you might get some of that money. But you'll never get a penny from the VC.
Thus, I would say that while there are excellent reasons to do business with a VC, if we are comparing them to clients I would say they are more demanding than clients while paradoxically giving you no money at all.
But you really pounded the financial nail into the coffin there :)
We're going to do it though. In our case we had the idea for the business before the idea for the product. I would not suggest doing it that way again, but that's just the way we were thinking at the time.
I don't agree with "always work on your best idea." My philosophy is "always work on the your best idea that is the nexus of being fun and earning you money soonest."
That's why my first SaaS is a time tracker, and not the giant perfect project management suite that lives on in my daydreams.
And the best reason to avoid VC is not so you can feel like an underdog, but because A) it's often a pyrrhic victory, and B) you add one more cook to the kitchen. I hate anyone telling me what to do. A VC is a client, in another form.