Craigslist is an odd case, because I think he did actually get rich by global standards, or at least, he has more money than most VC-backed entrepreneurs with exits have. Estimates vary, but he appears to make somewhere between $10m and $50m in cash dividends from CL per year, possibly more, which would put his cash net worth comfortably over $100m, not even including Craigslist equity. There are plenty of startups that don't exit at a level that pays the founder $100m+, and Craig still owns the business even after raking in that cash.
And their model is pretty clear. They are exchanging goods (posting space for job listings) for money.
The critique of free isn't that you can't give away a piece of candy to smooth over business, but that free isn't a business model.
but they don't charge in a way that maximizes short-term profits. they charge in a way that maximizes long-term viability. They only charge for listings /if/ the poster makes money off the listing /and/ the section is so full that thinning it a bit might be beneficial to the readers.
Re:Don’t bite the shit sandwich
by stanleydrew on Wednesday May 19, 2010 @11:19AM
(#1361193)
I wouldn't say Craig is working hard to make the free product good. I absolutely hate the fact that I have to use craigslist for apartment search. It is terrible (but simple, yes) and Craig has made a conscious decision to keep it that way.
compare it to Dice or monster. or, hell, realtor.com I think it's really, really easy to make your product /worse/ by adding features.
That said, I personally have a few projects on the back burner that directly compete with craigslist in a very limited way. it /can/ be improved. I'm just saying, for most of the space, by resisting the urge to 'make it better' craigslist has ended up being the dominant player because craigslist is the best. being light on features has kept them from screwing it up too badly.
Oh, totally. I only have a beef with "free" as business advice!
If you just wanna have fun, don't twist yourself into a pretzel trying to "monetize."
EDIT: Clarity!
BTW, http://everytimezone.com/ rocks! I've been using it quite a bit. Great work, hugely useful, free, and no pretzels.
That's the other side of 'free' - infrastructure is super cheap these days. If you build it because you think it is awesome, there's usually no need to get VC to rent servers.
Really, though, if you want to make money rather than just cover your costs, charging money for what you provide is the obvious choice.
My personal goal is to have a conventional 'charge money for goods and services' business that is successful enough to support me and my crew while we work on a few free 'because I think it would be awesome' boondogles, because that sort of thing is a lot of fun, you know?