There's also a good reason to believe that lots of people WOULD pay for something like Gmail.
Remember people trying to sell off invites back in the early days?
More importantly, having a direct line to the company controlling their email -- attached by money -- is a very appealing prospect for people who understand that free is dicey.
In the mean time, I'm making a lot of money selling things where there are tons of free alternatives. People don't pay for content? I made $40,000 writing & selling an ebook about rich web app performance.
I'm hardly the only one.
Lots of people would rather blame the market, blame the customer, or blame the economy than consider that maybe they didn't do due diligence.
I'll be writing a lot more about that in the future.
In that sense, figuring out how to monetize good but free services is a non-issue because you won't be building a good but free service.