Re:England to win World Cup, says JPM quant model
by patrickk on Wednesday May 19, 2010 @08:38AM
(#1360785)
In a top-class soccer match, you can't take your eyes off the action or you will miss something crucial. You could probably doze off for 20 minutes and miss little in a baseball game. Each to their own.
Just because you don't understand soccer isn't reason alone to describe it as "all over the place". It's a very exciting team sport (when played properly) and full of formations and tactics that coaches constantly try to innovate with:
The classic 4-4-2 formation
Beckenbauer's/Dutch football's 4-3-3
Jose Murinho's 4-5-1...Google em!
Also:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Formation_(football)#Common_mod...
Re:England to win World Cup, says JPM quant model
by mechanical_fish on Thursday May 20, 2010 @06:57PM
(#1365768)
You appear to have misinterpreted my sentence as some sort of insult. There's nothing wrong with being "all over the place"! No two minutes of soccer are exactly alike, but that is scarcely a bad thing!
The other point to make is that baseball controls the combinatorial explosion by either having the players act in relative isolation (when fielders handle the ball) or by grouping them in tiny groups of two or three (pitcher, batter, and to some extent the catcher), one of whom is generally a constant in any given game (the catcher), and one of whom only changes a few times per game (the pitcher). This is a fairly restricted set of possible matchups, and these are replayed over and over to get better stats. That's why baseball is the statistician's dream.
Similarly, in basketball there are fairly few players on the floor, and they tend to match up with each other fairly predictably. And while American football puts 22 players on the field, most of them never touch the ball, and most of the remaining players do the same sort of job over and over in the same relatively small part of the field, interacting with the same small subset of players on the other team.
But soccer is all over the place. ;)