News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anyone Can Become a Troll: Causes of Trolling Behavior in... by breatheoften on Tuesday February 07, 2017 @05:40PM (#13593639)
This is logically false -- it implies that no action, even deliberately undertaken can be called trolling -- which is just a ridiculous fluff claim. It's akin to saying "you can't talk about beauty because it doesn't exist".

At the very least, we can objectively define trolling when both the poster and at least one responder think a post is trolling. Reality actually allows far less strict definitions and there is nothing at all that prevents real empirical analysis to be performed on those concepts.

Your narrow logic is without merit and carries no ability to advance any communication on the topic at all.

Re:Anyone Can Become a Troll: Causes of Trolling Behavior in... by ouid on Tuesday February 07, 2017 @08:33PM (#13594897)
Calling something logically false, usually indicates that you have some sort of proof. Instead you've provided an inference without any supplementary reasoning, which yields a result which I think YOU think is a contradiction, but is not. Ie it would not be logically false to insist that no action, even deliberately undertaken, can objectively be called trolling.

Presumably, in an effort to remedy this, you attempt a construction, which fails in two ways.

First that is the skeeviest use of the word objective if I've ever seen. An objective definition is one which does not depend on the observer. To get around this, you have simply fixed two observers, thereby demonstrating the one to one correspondence of subjective statements and objective statements as follows:

I believe X is so ->

X' is so if I believe X is so.

This doesn't really count, I think, partly because of the second way the argument fails which is that your construction uses no properties OTHER than what these two observers think. In particular, the definition of troll, is formally equivalent to the following definition of ice cream. "if the poster, and at least one responder think it is ice cream then it is ice cream".

So before you invoke things phrases like "logically false" and "narrow logic", I think you should take a good hard look inward, and I mean this, of course, objectively.

Re:Anyone Can Become a Troll: Causes of Trolling Behavior in... by breatheoften on Tuesday February 07, 2017 @10:36PM (#13595480)
We are discussing trolling in the context of communication between groups of humans.

"Trolling is in the eye of the beholder" -- the intuitive basis for this claim is that there cannot be a method for establishing agreement about what is and is not trolling. I offered a minimal definition of trolling for which constructing agreement is clearly possible.

My toy example is just to illustrate that there exist ways to construct or approximate agreement on what trolling is -- there are in fact many ways to construct such agreement. Pretending like such agreement is impossible is a strategy to empower trolls.

I'll partially accept your pedantic criticism over my use of the phrase "logically false" -- but your attempt to disparage my use of the word Objective is welcome to go sit alone with you in a motionless universe for the rest of eternity.

Re:Anyone Can Become a Troll: Causes of Trolling Behavior in... by ouid on Tuesday February 07, 2017 @10:51PM (#13595564)
Let me put it another way. In your construction, if I make a post, and someone makes a comment on a post which a responder then describes as trolling, How may I objectively determine whether or not that comment qualified as trolling?

Since I am the poster, and at least one responder has called it trolling, it is now trolling if and only if I say it is trolling. In this case, I have no objective definition to look to. This is both a real world case, and a case where your definition is degenerate, which I would call a critical failure of your definition.

Re:Anyone Can Become a Troll: Causes of Trolling Behavior in... by breatheoften on Tuesday February 07, 2017 @11:16PM (#13595706)
Either you agree it's trolling (establishing the fact that your post was trolling with respect to the toy definition) or you disagree (establishing that the post was not trolling with respect to the definition).

Either way it's possible to label the post as trolling or not with respect to the toy definition and it's possible for observers to agree about that label.

My response to the original beholder subjectivity claim is not about whether a thing "is" trolling or not, it's about whether people can agree a thing "is" trolling or not. There are plenty of sufficiently good methods for people to agree about this designation that we don't need to invoke a Plato's spheres argument asserting that "trolling doesn't exist".

Re:Anyone Can Become a Troll: Causes of Trolling Behavior in... by ouid on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @04:24AM (#13596972)
You claimed that the notion of definition by agreement was sufficient to demonstrate the existence of some objective definition compatible with the first. I have plainly proven that false.
Re:Anyone Can Become a Troll: Causes of Trolling Behavior in... by breatheoften on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @11:49AM (#13599723)
In the real universe, objective only ever exists relative to some set of observers.

You have proven nothing I said false, you merely interpreted the words I used in a way that does not treat the implication that some interpretations of words which do not admit the possibility for such concepts as human communication to exist, are flawed interpretations with respect to the set of observations about human communication that it is possible to make (which show that human communication does exist). That's the original fallacy I pointed out which you rejected as non-fallacious because you seem to not believe that it is possible to talk about consistency of agreement between sets of communicating humans in objective terms.

You think you've exposed a flaw in my argument but really you've just been spinning your wheels on misconstructions of what I said -- from my perspective either your interpretive process has misled you or you have engaged in a deliberate process of failing to communicate.

Re:Anyone Can Become a Troll: Causes of Trolling Behavior in... by ouid on Wednesday February 08, 2017 @05:09PM (#13602656)
I have been failing to communicate, but it has not been deliberate.

Your assertion that there is no such thing as objective truth is A) false and B) not a reason to redefine objective truth (a property that is impossible to obtain is still a useful thing to talk about).

Humanity does not generate the properties that it invents language to describe. Those properties can be thought of objectively, but natural language does not always do that (it does do it sometimes though, the word "three" is objectively defined).

Some words do not contain within their definition any objective phenomena; "Beauty", for example, does not. The reasoning you have applied thus far should apply to all words, since you have not expressed any particular property of 'troll' in any of your arguments. So if the original comment had said "beauty is in the eye of the beholder", and we had continued to have this same argument, the validity of either of our positions would be unchanged. Would you still be complaining about relativism if that had been the topic?

Re:Anyone Can Become a Troll: Causes of Trolling Behavior in... by khedoros1 on Tuesday February 07, 2017 @06:31PM (#13594079)
> This is logically false -- it implies that no action, even deliberately undertaken can be called trolling

I took it more as an expression of something like Poe's Law. If someone says something inflammatory, is it a troll, or is it an honest expression of opinion? You can theorize about the author's mental state, but you can't know what they're thinking. Without extra information, the difference rests in the reader's perception.

Re:Anyone Can Become a Troll: Causes of Trolling Behavior in... by breatheoften on Tuesday February 07, 2017 @07:20PM (#13594415)
With respect to any particular objective definition of trolling, there may exist perfect snowflake comments that are not trolling but are identified as such by the definition.

There exist plenty of definitions that can be imagined which make the above snowflakes very rare in practice.

If the beholder argument is that the existence of a single such snowflake invalidates the possibility that useful objectivity can be used to study the concept of trolling -- then the claim is ludicrous. We can study the notion of trolling without getting every single label right every time.

Re:Anyone Can Become a Troll: Causes of Trolling Behavior in... by khedoros1 on Tuesday February 07, 2017 @08:07PM (#13594742)
> If the beholder argument is that the existence of a single such snowflake invalidates the possibility that useful objectivity can be used to study the concept of trolling -- then the claim is ludicrous.

Agreed, but I don't think we're talking about snowflakes. I think we're talking about a significant portion of the communication out there that might be identified by some as "trolling". And I guess I'm less interested in an objective definition of trolling than I am in an objective determination of whether some particular post or group of posts is intended as a troll.

On top of that, I don't think it's a binary determination. There's such a thing as a 100% troll post or a 100% innocent post, but there's also everything in between.

Re:Anyone Can Become a Troll: Causes of Trolling Behavior in... by breatheoften on Tuesday February 07, 2017 @10:47PM (#13595548)
I'm more interested in the side of the spectrum containing the posts that are the most clearly likely to be agreed upon as examples of trolling. It's my opinion that way too many of this variety of trolling voice (augmented by bots) has been shouting trolling messages at groups of people in a way that discourages real attempts at communication. I see this kind of messaging as a way of isolating communities from each other and blocking avenues of communication between perspectives that would otherwise evolve organically.