That kind of system promotes poor and expensive health.
Yes, services and goods procured, even necessary services and goods like food, clothing and housing, cost money.
If you're arguing that no life necessities should cost money, I'm afraid you're not going to get anywhere with the non-socialist crowd. Since most Americans are non-socialist, this is not a politically tenable position. Do you have an objection that isn't "it should cost literally no money"?
The US has a (admittedly obfuscated) fee based health care system. However, if one necessarily needs medical treatment, you can go to an ER it will be provided to you. You might end up with a debt that you can never pay but you won't be turned away. These emergency visits actually account for a large amount of the US government health care costs.
So if your society accepts that all people will be treated regardless of their ability pay then you might as well start looking at better and cheaper ways of doing that. Waiting till someone is so sick that they need the ER is a huge waste and bogs down the entire system; even for paying users! By comparison, simple doctors visits are considerably less expensive and produce better outcomes than waiting until people have no other option.
As for socialism, your society doesn't want to let people starve either and provides plenty of mechanisms to prevent that too. Socialism is automatically baked into any society that won't let the poorest or the sickest simply die.
http://visual.ons.gov.uk/how-does-uk-healthcare-spending-com...
Government spending (not including insurance)
> Despite less than half of the USA’s total healthcare expenditure coming from government expenditure or compulsory insurance schemes, it still spends more per person on these financing schemes than the UK- £3,111 in the USA in 2014, compared with £2,210 in the UK. In the USA spending on privately-funded healthcare is over five times more per person than in the UK.
No one is going after the industrial profiteers and exploiters here. People either want to leave those profiteers completely alone or force them to continue to be paid exorbitant rates by the government (that only look non-exorbitant by comparison to other nations where they're even higher). Those are both bad answers! The marketplace must be kickstarted so it can stay in the hands of the people, surrendered to neither government bureaucrats (as proposed by pro-universal healthcare advocates) nor heartless capitalists (as is mostly the current state).
We need to start from first principles here and say "What does a sick person need to get better, and how can we provide that in a cost-efficient way that allows medicine to be like all the rest of our industries: open to competition, appropriately regulated, and run by fair and competitive private enterprises?"
This is obviously not a sustainable or mature solution to the problem, but it's a band-aid that appears to relieve much of the burden involved for patients.
I broke it out once and my net salary would be about $1k less than what I receive now if I lived in Canada instead of the U.S. I know that those extra taxes aren't all directly attributable to the health care apparatus, but the unverified impression is that a lot of it goes to that.
There have been periods when I've had to pay more than $1000/mo on medical bills on an ongoing basis, and there's pretty much always at least $500/mo going out to medical payments of some type or another in our family of 7. Our credit has also been routinely hounded by the medical industry's inability to figure out its own billing. Is avoiding all of that worth a net loss of $500/mo? Probably.
The polarization in America is really sad. We need to acknowledge that these are legitimate issues. Republicans need to take their heads out of the sand and quit just shrieking that "we have the best health care in the world!!!! We're America, bitch!", and Democrats need to respect that Republicans don't think "Just have the government pay for it and increase taxation commensurately" is an acceptable solution. Let's get away from each others' throats and try to figure this out constructively.
IMO the best option is to outlaw non-catastrophic medical insurance, set up new, temporary medical device and pharmaceutical suppliers who sell brand-name products at a loss, make serious revisions to the terms of drug patents, remove any applicable governmental subsidies that encourage reckless, unsustainable expansion of medical facilities, and make a law that says medical bills cannot be included in any credit worthiness determination.
This converts everyone to self-pay, which means medical providers will have to charge prices that real people can actually pay, it will end the absurd pricing showdowns and billing shenanigans between providers and insurers that often leave patients as collateral damage, it will undercut the supply chain that ratchets up the costs for everyone on the way down to the patient, it will discourage hospitals from building extravagant campuses that rival universities and instead focus on affordable, utilitarian designs, and so on.
I can hardly think of a worse solution than "just make everyone get an insurance policy and leave everything else essentially the same", aka Obamacare/Romneycare.
That should take us a long way to a sustainable, market-based solution. But it's clear at this point that some governmental action is needed to grease the wheels here.