The "theft" part occurs when someone is assigned that SSN starts using it and finds out that they have $300,000 in bad loans on their credit file. This is usually a kid who is applying for student loans or their first car loan. Then they must spend time/money cleaning up their credit file.
http://news.debix.com/index.php/2008/11/teenager-tarnished-b...
Discolsure: I'm a former employee and current investor in Debix.
And that's when I realized how easy it is to steal a person's identity.
Verifying the SSN using that service for banking (as I'm reading it) is a clear violation of the system.
Reference (http://www.ssa.gov/employer/ssnvshandbk/ssnvs_bso.htm)
If you were using a different service I'd be interested, as we are always looking for new ways to do validation of accounts.
http://www.ssa.gov/ and http://www.socialsecurity.gov both have a lot of useful information about structure and allocation of SSNs if you are looking to do something similar.
I cross-referenced the SSN death index to ensure dead people had not risen from the grave to apply for credit. I also excluded the popular "fake" SSNs used in advertising (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Security_number#SSNs_inv...), and I most definitely added Todd Davis's number to the list. This last step seemed like a no-brainer given all of the publicity at the time.
While I can understand a small boutique store not going to those lengths to prevent a fraudulent account, I am a little surprised that AT&T and Verizon were among the casualties.