Re:IDPF, EPUB Standardizing Body, Has Combined with W3C
by jcranmer on Monday February 06, 2017 @06:11PM
(#13585227)
If a new version of, say, Chrome were to drop the Mozilla/5.0 from its UA and break a website because it relied on Mozilla/* in its UA detection (there are STILL sites that do this), who would users blame? Chrome, obviously.
If you're trying to make a new web browser, it's even worse--people won't use it if it breaks the sites that use it. And the web developer would say "it works in all the major browsers, what's wrong with it and why should I spend the time to fix it for your shitty new browser?"
The problem is that the blame for broken sites is universally attributed to browsers, not website developers.
Re:IDPF, EPUB Standardizing Body, Has Combined with W3C
by kuschku on Monday February 06, 2017 @07:14PM
(#13585720)
That’s why you create a new version that is specifically not backwards-compatible with the old one, ensure all tools have appropriate linters already existing, browsers in developer mode or beta/dev versions fail on such sites, etc; and then let websites opt-in to the new version with a special header.
Re:IDPF, EPUB Standardizing Body, Has Combined with W3C
by jcranmer on Monday February 06, 2017 @08:38PM
(#13586189)
That has been tried before, and that has failed. One of the things that HTML5 fixed was the DOCTYPE mess (in fact, the <!DOCTYPE html> represents the minimal string that enabled standards mode in every browser, including IE). In addition to standards/quirks mode (and the concurrent but separate HTML/XHTML issues), Mozilla tried versioning JS (that was ripped out), and IE tried the compatibility mode switches.
It should be noted that later versions of IE eventually gave up and joined the crowd by having its UA string pretend to be Chrome, which pretends to be Safari, which pretends to be Firefox, which pretends to be Netscape.
All other documents I read have been updated in the meantime.
If an entire country can update centuries of material in a few years, why is it so hard to update some simple websites, or, in case that’s not possible, ship a polyfill as Addon?