News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trump’s F.C.C. Pick Quickly Targets Net Neutrality Rules by _archon_ on Monday February 06, 2017 @04:47PM (#13584466)
I think instant runoff voting is optimal, but it's too confusing for an idiot in a hurry. I'd be content with simple approval voting. Every candidate has a checkbox next to their name on the ballot. If you approve of the candidate, check the box. Most checks wins. Ballot will have a lot of names, but that's the price of democracy.
Re:Trump’s F.C.C. Pick Quickly Targets Net Neutrality Rules by ScottBurson on Monday February 06, 2017 @06:15PM (#13585247)
I too think AV (Approval Voting) is the best. It's bog simple to explain [ETA: and to implement using existing voting equipment], and completely immune from both strategic candidate selection and strategic voting. Its only downside, IMO, is reduced detectability of vote count tampering: there's no simple relationship between the number of voters and the number of votes, as there is with plurality voting or even IRV. So if you're going to use AV, you have to have an auditable paper trail. That's a very good idea anyway, of course, and lots of places are moving in that direction, so I don't think this is really a barrier.

(For very small numbers of voters, such as for elections within an academic society, Rating Voting is even better, but its advantages fade as the number of voters increases. AV is just the limiting case of RV with only two values.)

Re:Trump’s F.C.C. Pick Quickly Targets Net Neutrality Rules by vinay427 on Tuesday February 07, 2017 @06:37AM (#13588713)
> there's no simple relationship between the number of voters and the number of votes, as there is with plurality voting or even IRV

This problem still exists in FPTP where some voters may opt not to vote for any candidate for a position.

Re:Trump’s F.C.C. Pick Quickly Targets Net Neutrality Rules by dragonwriter on Monday February 06, 2017 @04:56PM (#13584569)
> I think instant runoff voting is optimal

It's very nearly the worst actually proposed single-member ranked ballots system; I can't imagine any way in which it is optimal. It's better than FPTP, but that's a pretty low bar.