How can people on your side, in one argument say it isn't stealing to copy music, but it is stealing to enter into an agreement whereby one party exchanges something (music) for something else (money) and all parties freely choose to do so?
Please, those 'agreements' were put together by the best shyster lawyers to put artists in debt even if they were successful.
> How can people on your side, in one argument say it isn't stealing to copy music, but it is stealing to enter into an agreement whereby one party exchanges something (music) for something else (money) and all parties freely choose to do so?
Because 'just because it is written on a piece of paper and has a signature under it' doesn't make it right.
The music industry had turned fraud in to an art form.
Arists that don't get paid royalties, artists that are signed to a label only to find out there is no intention to produce, artists that are screwed in to being in major debt just because of some fine print clause that you'd have to be another shyster lawyer to spot and so on. The list is endless.
And then we're not yet talking about price fixing, the war on fair use (especially sampling) and so on.
And don't get me started on stupidity like the 'happy birthday' thing and Mickey Mouse and copyright.
Really. If you want to be the champion of something find a group or a cause that is worthy of it, the major labels are not, and plenty of the smaller ones are not much better.
If A list artists have a problem you can bet your life that it is worse at the lower rungs of the ladder.
At a friends (who is an artist, and a fairly famous one here in NL, several major hits and an enormous repertoire of songs for third parties) invitation I went to a local BUMA/STEMRA meeting a year ago, it was unbelievable how strong the disconnect is between the rights organizations, the labels and the artists.
This world needs shaking up, badly.
I don't care about the major labels, what I care about is maintaining a social structure where creativity can be rewarded and the investment and time put into great quality intellectual products isn't wasted.
> I don't care about the major labels, what I care about is maintaining a social structure where creativity can be rewarded and the investment and time put into great quality intellectual products isn't wasted.
Such a structure will eventually unfold, we're looking at a lively market here.
Just like open source didn't kill software development wholesale copying won't kill the music market. But it will kill the current business model.
bit sharing and open source are two topics that are so religious around here. This community has a huge axe to grind against powerful organizations who have profited off intellectual property. Why?
What exactly is so wrong about profiting off intellectual property? Software, music, movies?
Because the current system works by an artificial monopoly. Monopolies harm the public. The compensation that copyright is supposed to provide -- incentivising production -- is not clearly supported by evidence. And the restriction inherent in monopolised distribution is fundamentally opposed to the new benefits that the internet offers -- if we want one, the other must be reduced -- and we want the internet.
The problem is not people profiting from creating, it is that the system has been rigged by current encumbents to rip-off and obstruct the public.
That argument holds true for a literal florist but as an analogy to filesharing it really breaks down pretty quickly, after all the garden would never empty of flowers 'taken' if they were copied. Your argument below that they are not 'free' because they take up server space and electricity and so on are also not valid because the storage, electricity and server space is not exactly provided by the original authors in the case of a pirated copy.
The whole piracy thing is a backlash against people that have been stealing from artists and consumers both.
Go read Janis Ians writing on this, or Courtney Love, or countless of other artists that have spoken up about this.
Times are changing, we'll find a new equilibrium and those that had a free ride for a long time will have to find a different racket at some point. Technically speaking they're already dead.
It will just take a while longer before we get there.
Artists that make music for the love of their work will continue to do so, and will find a way to make money. Artists that are creations of the media machine will have a problem, but then again, most of them weren't in it for the art to begin with so there is probably not much lost there.
I can't even name one band launched in the last 5 years that stood out for me that was not an indie band.