Re:Show HN: Personal finance with 'hledger' in Emacs
by cJ0th on Sunday February 05, 2017 @10:03AM
(#13572636)
If you have used gnuCash before what would you say makes hledger better?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Show HN: Personal finance with 'hledger' in Emacs
by BeetleB on Saturday February 11, 2017 @03:00PM
(#13624462)
I used GnuCash years ago, then switched to KMyMoney. Now I use a hybrid of KMyMoney and ledger. The former makes it easier to enter transactions. Then I run a script that parses the KMyMoney file and creates a ledger output.
Better?
For me primarily: If you do envelope type budgeting, GnuCash does not support it. ledger/hledger does with virtual transactions (although hledger discourages it).
Other than that, I think there are other benefits. I could never remember the ledger/hledger syntax, but they conveniently let you export to csv, and I use Python scripts with pandas to extract what I want.
If there's any calculation you would like to do, it's easier with these tools. Say, for example, you want to calculate the effective rate of return for all your investments combined. I don't think GnuCash will let you do that across accounts, etc.