Before the Great Depression, mortgages were completely private – homeowners would generally string refinances one after another, and mortgage terms were less than 5 years. It wasn’t until 1934 that the Federal Housing Administration stepped in with an insurance program on mortgages, an amortization plan, and terms of 15-20 years (much like today, many mortgages are insured based on standardized programs – say, 30 years, fixed interest, 80% loan to value).
[1]https://dqydj.com/history-30-year-mortgage-private-mortgage-...
My understanding is that is pretty similar to the US, but it sounds different to Canada.
We don't have the same tax breaks as in the US though.
It's really quite amazing if you think about it.
I know a guy who refinanced a few years back at 2.89%. That's insane as it's barely above inflation. He's basically borrowing money for free.
If inflation goes up to 5-7% over the coming years, his rate will stay at 2.89%, drastically decreasing the cost to pay it back.
That said, most loan originators sell the mortgage off. Many of those go to quasi governmental corporations that most people believe the US tax payers will bail out if necessary.
We have fixed-rate mortgages in Norway too, but the interest rate loss or gain is realized when you refinance. Meaning that if you refinance to a lower rate, you'll have to pay the loss taken by the bank, and if you refinance to a higher rate, the bank pays you the loss you take. If you pay off the loan faster than scheduled, the same rules apply. So the risk is taken entirely by the borrower.
There's not really a loss, since the terms of your old loan allowed the early repayment.
The mortgage is essentially a 30 year option, in those terms it becomes obvious why 30 year fixed mortgages wouldn't exist in an unsubsidized market.
They may have (potentially) had a few month's worth of being underwater but they were able to borrow at a lower rate also.
Further, there are several %age points of spread between what banks pay to borrow and what the mortgage rate is, further cushioning them. See the CIDOR here: http://www.tradingeconomics.com/canada/interbank-rate ... now compare with the mortgage rates a bank will charge.
EDIT: CIDOR under 1% but ratehub.ca says the best 5-year fixed rate you can get is... 2.42% .
Tax breaks of course is another thing that massively influences US mortgages. I probably would never take my current mortgage if not the interest tax break.
To me, massive government subsidies is more like in France where you can have a 0% interest 25 year mortgage if your household income is low enough.
Or the special account which gives a 2.6% fixed interest after having saved some money in a special savings account.
In addition VA loans & FHA loan security is applied to something like 45% of loans. I've seen estimates that suggest the US taxpayer backs or owns 60% of loans in the residential market.
Do you mean the interest rate is fixed for only five years? If so, people will not need to refinance as long as interest rates stay low.
What would be really terrifying would be another period of stagflation (no growth, high inflation). You could see your salary stay the same, but your mortgage payments increase by 20-40% when you refinance.
The truly terrifying thing is that the banks have been adding clauses to the mortgages that on renewal if the market value drops below the outstanding balance, the homeowner is required to pay the difference in order to renew.
This is scary because they will not have paid off much in the first 5 years, but the house price can certainly drop a lot in 5 years in a down market, and there would be very little hope for finding a new lender willing to offer a new mortgage for more than the market value of the house.
Getting a mortgage in Canada is (in my experience) a very weird process for an agreement over such a large sum, but typically can happen within a week.
even if interest rates are flat (or go down, even) you can still be forced into foreclosure if your equity in the home drops below an acceptable threshold
In Canada, they don't have fixed 30-year mortgages like in the US. They have 25-year mortgages with 5 year terms. They need to refinance within 5 years. If they take a 20-30% hit in the house costs, they will absolutely be unable to renew their mortgage, unless they come up with the cash to make up the difference in appraised value.
This will lead to a lot of forced selling or foreclosures which will only pull the house prices down further, and cause more forced selling.