News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Save Mozilla Firefox's Best Feature by yalogin on Saturday February 04, 2017 @10:35AM (#13567272)
I don't get it. If Mozilla thinks this is the best route for them they should do it. Input on features like that shouldnt be taken from users who will not have the long term view of firefox.
Re:Save Mozilla Firefox's Best Feature by nocman on Saturday February 04, 2017 @11:28AM (#13567521)
"If Mozilla thinks this is the best route for them they should do it"

I'm all for Mozilla having the power to make good technical decisions, but it sounds like you are suggesting that Mozilla ignore their user base completely. That's a recipe for the death of Firefox, IMHO.

I know there are technical reasons that Mozilla is wanting to get rid of XUL, and those reasons look legitimate to me. The problem I see is that they don't have a replacement for XUL that affords the same level of customizability that it does. I've done a little work with XUL, and yes, it's no picnic. I would welcome an alternative that was simpler, and better designed. However, if the replacement only offers a fraction of the flexibility of XUL, then addon developers aren't going to like it.

"Input on features like that shouldnt be taken from users who will not have the long term view of firefox."

^ That's a pretty broad brush you are painting with there. There are a huge number of us who have been using Firefox since it was released in 2004 (and Netscape Navigator before that). I haven't taken a formal survey, but the feedback I've seen from the long-term users is that the depth of customizability available via Firefox's addons is one of the primary reasons they continue to use the browser after all of these years.

Also, I would venture to guess that the people most likely to continue using Firefox are these dedicated long-term users. But if Mozilla insists on ignoring the wishes of these users, they will lose the strongest advocates in their user base.

Ignoring your users is a terrible idea.

Again, I welcome a replacement for XUL. Just make it a full-featured replacement, and don't cut off XUL development until said replacement is indeed full-featured and reasonably stable.

Maybe Mozilla can't pull that off, but I would certainly like to see them try.

Re:Save Mozilla Firefox's Best Feature by maxerickson on Saturday February 04, 2017 @11:36AM (#13567565)
They tend to follow their wider userbase quite closely.

It's a small fraction of advanced users that think Mozilla ignores them.

Re:Save Mozilla Firefox's Best Feature by nocman on Saturday February 04, 2017 @11:55AM (#13567672)
Got some data to back that up? (not saying you don't, I'd honestly like to know if you do).

I personally have not heard any users say anything wildly positive about recent changes. And I think the steady decline in users is in a large part due to the perception that Mozilla doesn't seem to care what their users want anymore.

I don't think it is a "small fraction". I think it's a big chunk. And I also think that chunk constitutes the most dedicated users the browser has (you know, the kind that install Firefox on their relatives' computers for them, and frequently personally advocate its use by others). Mozilla would be fools to ignore them.

I honestly hold only a small amount of hope that Firefox will live on long term. These issues keep being brought up, and Mozilla still comes across like they don't care. Feedback I've gotten from folks who work at Mozilla indicates that at least some of them do care, but the public perception by loyal users is that they don't.

I hope Mozilla can get it together and that Firefox can live on with great success. At this point I just don't think it is going to happen. I hope they prove me wrong.

[edited to correct punctuation]

Re:Save Mozilla Firefox's Best Feature by anotheryou on Saturday February 04, 2017 @11:52AM (#13567656)
Can you give an example? The only FF people I know love extentions (to be honest I don't know many anymore, even here in germany), the others are on chrome or safari.
Re:Save Mozilla Firefox's Best Feature by SAI_Peregrinus on Saturday February 04, 2017 @10:47AM (#13567328)
The only reason I use Firefox is the TreeStyle Tabs addon. Everything else I could get from Chromium or another browser. If WebExtensions don't get the needed features, I'll simply end up dumping Firefox. That said, there's still time and WebExt might get such features.
Re:Save Mozilla Firefox's Best Feature by DiThi on Saturday February 04, 2017 @10:49AM (#13567337)
Tree Style Tabs is also the #1 reason for me.
Re:Save Mozilla Firefox's Best Feature by taivare on Saturday February 04, 2017 @11:11AM (#13567432)
are Tree Style Tabs an extension or now built-in.
Re:Save Mozilla Firefox's Best Feature by detaro on Saturday February 04, 2017 @11:19AM (#13567479)
Re:Save Mozilla Firefox's Best Feature by atopal on Saturday February 04, 2017 @10:53AM (#13567353)
Can you say why you would drop Firefox for Chromium?
Re:Save Mozilla Firefox's Best Feature by barrkel on Saturday February 04, 2017 @10:57AM (#13567372)

  Firefox-now: TreeStyleTabs + ok browser
  Chromium-now: fast browser
  Firefox-future: ok browser
  Chromium-future: fast browser
As long as TreeStyleTabs > (fast browser - ok browser), then Firefox is a better choice. Without TreeStyleTabs, Chromium (or Chrome, or whatever fork is better at protecting privacy) is the better choice.
Re:Save Mozilla Firefox's Best Feature by nandhp on Saturday February 04, 2017 @11:38AM (#13567578)
I believe one of the key reasons for dropping XUL extensions is because they don't work very well with e10s (multiprocess Firefox). I recently had occasion to use a fresh Firefox without any e10s-incompatible extensions installed, and it really felt much faster, so I think Firefox-future may also qualify as "fast browser".
Re:Save Mozilla Firefox's Best Feature by tgsovlerkhgsel on Saturday February 04, 2017 @10:57AM (#13567374)
I perceive it as more polished, and think it is more secure (built-in Flash that gets extremely fast updates, and I believe more/better sandboxing).

With the key advantage of Firefox (customizability) gone, the question turns into "why NOT drop Firefox for Chrome/Chromium".

Re:Save Mozilla Firefox's Best Feature by atopal on Saturday February 04, 2017 @11:05AM (#13567403)
But Mozilla claims that it's exactly the old add-on system that keeps Firefox from being more secure. What if they were just as secure as Chrome after giving up on the old add-on system? Wouldn't it make more sense for them to compete without the disadvantage of being the less secure browser?
Re:Save Mozilla Firefox's Best Feature by protomyth on Saturday February 04, 2017 @11:25AM (#13567515)
I get the feeling that a lot of users really don't believe XUL, etc. is inherently less secure. I cannot say either way myself, but without the capability of the old plugin system Firefox has no real advantage over Chrome. It probably doesn't help that they are going with something compatible with Chrome which leads to a "why not just use the original" thought process.

I get the feeling that they could have got the new system done and as capable as the old before deleting the old. Transition periods are brutal as Python and Perl have found out.

Re:Save Mozilla Firefox's Best Feature by krakensden on Saturday February 04, 2017 @11:47AM (#13567618)
That's not really true. Chrome is more secure because it's designed better, they have very good and mature sandboxing for the parts of the browser that work with data from the internet, and because they work very hard at improving their codebase. They have their own LLVM fork!

WebExtensions can still read all your data on all websites and inject whatever they want into all websites. Not a lot of security there. That is OK though, I am fine trusting Google and Gorhill instead of just Google.