News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:React Tetris by markdown on Saturday February 04, 2017 @04:01AM (#13566311)
Did you feel better after posting that?

I think it's a very cool project.

Re:React Tetris by omegote on Saturday February 04, 2017 @04:39AM (#13566392)
I honestly think he has a point. There are hundreds of implementations of Tetris for any kind of platform and technology. This is only noteworthy (for some, at least, not for me) because it's build with React.

By the way, it's pretty dumb and shortsighted to depict flash as a neanderthal, because both its capabilities and its ease of use are (were) way beyond what current JS frameworks offer today (and in the upcoming years, at least).

Re:React Tetris by kristopolous on Saturday February 04, 2017 @08:34AM (#13566901)
Not only, but it achieved this 20 years ago, on computers of 20 years ago, and on internet connections of 20 years ago.

We've seemed to replace the merits of direct functional efficiency with a novelty of complexity.

Re:React Tetris by watwut on Saturday February 04, 2017 @03:07PM (#13568772)
Unfortunately, flash became uncool and it seems that tech community lately value "cool" over, well, anything else lately.
Re:React Tetris by watwut on Saturday February 04, 2017 @03:06PM (#13568761)
Yup, react part makes it noteworthy, worth bookmarking and learning from. Also that this implementation is actually fun to play, most of them are not.

This is how people and communities learn. They do small projects to see what is achievable. There is nothing shameful about it.

About the parent poster: he is just an adult equivalent of a kid that came into the room, scrapped other kids drawings and told them they are all suckers. Otherwise said, just someone having emotional meltdown and taking it on the random people around. No reason to take him seriously.

Re:React Tetris by daliwali on Sunday February 05, 2017 @01:22PM (#13573650)
If this were a student project or an intellectual exercise to implement Tetris in an obscure language, good on them. I can respect that.

However it is undeniable that there are overkill levels of abstractions in play here, for the purpose of using what is currently the most commercially viable web framework. This is like taking FizzBuzz Enterprise Edition seriously for being written in Java.

>just someone having emotional meltdown and taking it on the random people around

I won't stoop down to your level of using personal attacks. You don't know me.

Re:React Tetris by lewisl9029 on Saturday February 04, 2017 @09:39AM (#13567098)
> By the way, it's pretty dumb and shortsighted to depict flash as a neanderthal, because both its capabilities and its ease of use are (were) way beyond what current JS frameworks offer today (and in the upcoming years, at least).

You're taking his depiction of Flash out of context.

https://github.com/chvin/react-tetris/blob/master/README-EN....

He was clearly only comparing the different solutions in terms of audio capabilities.

I can appreciate how much of a gigantic leap in capabilities Web Audio API offers compared to HTML5 audio alone, so I can vouch for that part of his depiction.

I haven't ever worked with Flash audio, nor Flash itself in general though, so you may still be right about him being unfair and shortsighted in making that comparison in the context of audio capabilities, but I think it's still an important distinction to make if that was in fact your critique.

Re:React Tetris by omegote on Sunday February 05, 2017 @06:48AM (#13571949)
I know he was talking about the audio, but my critique works both about flash in general and about audio support in particular.

ELEVEN YEARS ago Flash was already capable of both playing and recording audio from multiple sources, using several different codecs and offering the usual bells and whistles you're expected to find in any multimedia framework (vis.eq., channels, etc). And everything working exactly the same way in every browser equipped with a flash player.

And I'm taking eleven years ago because that's when AS3 was released. Flash had considerable audio support before that anyway.

[dead]
Re:React Tetris by afarrell on Saturday February 04, 2017 @06:59AM (#13566679)
"Nobody cares about what type of stitching, what the source of the fabric, or what artistic inspirations a garment has. All that matters is the comfort and aesthetics of the wearer."

Every hobby, craft, and profession has people making things that aren't for the end market user, but are for the education of the maker/practitioner. If you're not interested in it, thats fine. If you want to critique the user experience as a way of constructively learning/teaching about user experience, thats great.

If you just want to come here and fart on people for not always being 100% focused on the market... why?

Re:React Tetris by daliwali on Saturday February 04, 2017 @08:05AM (#13566841)
>If you just want to come here and fart on people for not always being 100% focused on the market... why?

We are posting on a website run by a venture capital firm, maybe you can explain why the market is not relevant here.

As far as education goes, it's about learning how to use a particular framework, which is highly temporal knowledge and makes use of mostly crystallized intelligence. It's problematic and largely inefficient that most web developers jump from framework to framework as the market dictates. There is an endless cycle of learning mostly temporal knowledge that's discarded as soon as the next framework comes.

People talk of fundamental CS skills, but in reality it's almost never needed in web development, where there's frameworks that abstract everything away. A tetris clone in vanilla JS would perform much better, and the code would be more directly relevant to the application, but rarely is anyone hired to do just that. It serves business interests more to have developers who are conventional, easily replaceable cogs in a machine.

Re:React Tetris by lewisl9029 on Saturday February 04, 2017 @09:02AM (#13566992)
> We are posting on a website run by a venture capital firm, maybe you can explain why the market is not relevant here.

I can help with that: https://news.ycombinator.com/showhn.html

Pay special attention to these sections:

    Show HN is a way to share something that you've made on Hacker News.

    Be respectful. Anyone sharing work is making a contribution, however modest. 

    When something isn't good, you needn't pretend that it is. But don't be gratuitously negative. 
If you're looking for polished, commercial products with a laser-focus on satisfying the needs of a market, please be aware that's not what Show HN is all about.

Yes, some of those do show up here rather often due to the nature of the community, and in those cases, comments like yours can be considered fair game, and they might even be helpful in some cases.

This particular Show HN, however, is very clearly just a passionate engineer sharing something they've built in their spare time for fun and learning. Those guidelines I highlighted earlier are precisely in place to protect the rather significant portion of the community here who, like the author of this Show HN, happen to enjoy building, sharing, trying out, (constructively) critiquing, and learning from these kinds of projects.

If you don't share that mindset, that's perfectly fine, but if you're going to comment on a project like this, please just be more mindful of the context next time.

Re:React Tetris by KingOfMyRoom on Saturday February 04, 2017 @08:35AM (#13566903)
> We are posting on a website run by a venture capital firm, maybe you can explain why the market is not relevant here.

Such a cynical world view. At least Don Quixote was fighting for a good cause.

Re:React Tetris by fermuch on Saturday February 04, 2017 @06:06AM (#13566574)
The audience of hacker news can understand and appreciate the work behind this tetris clone. Yes, it's a clone and there're millions, but this one is very well made and can work very much as an example of the technology being showcased this time (react)
Re:React Tetris by joshwcomeau on Saturday February 04, 2017 @07:14AM (#13566711)
Hackernews is not ProductHunt. People show off things they've built here to be admired by other craftsmen/craftswomen, not to market to a general audience.

Your attitude is toxic, although I'm thankful you phrased it in such a juvenile way. Nobody will take you seriously when you talk like that.

Re:React Tetris by kristopolous on Saturday February 04, 2017 @06:56AM (#13566670)
Although I agree, this is not the place to have that soundoff.

Write an article about how people fetishize complicated solutions to simple problems and how it creates a dysfunctional complexity and egocentric culture without focusing on the merits of appropriate solutions to appropriate problems. It'd be a good read.

But not in the comment section here since this was clearly a hobbyist project and not as an attack. The merits of the claim are lost in the hostility of the execution.