That said, there is no need to only have one argument, they can both stand together.
As best I can tell, we have no moral obligation to let every person into the United States, but we have an economically-sound reason for accepting a steady stream of new folks.
Really thoughtful comment though, thanks.
In the long run, sure. But in the short run, were there Irish gangs, German mafia &c.? Were those forms of criminality different from the forms prevalent amonst ethnic-English Americans of the same time period? I honestly don't know.
What sort of social upheaval and strife occurred along the way to assimilation? In the long run, things might be okay, but how much pain will there be along the way?
Criminality us a result of being marginalized from society and not being able to work "honest" livings. You are forced to rely on your own group, pushed to the edges and fighting for its own.
This doesn't make it okay, of course. This means we need to be that much more conscious of it, and take active steps to mitigate the effects of racism. (This is the distinction between "I'm not a racist" and anti-racism, btw)
Established groups feared new groups. But in the end, these people generally brought new innovations and economic growth and interesting new foods.
They mashed new cultures with old - not without pain - and eventually gave us General Tso's Chicken.
In other words, it's gonna be alright.
^^ this is what I tell people who support Muslim bans. I'm not sure if it helps them, but it helps me.