News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by gozur88 on Thursday February 02, 2017 @10:29PM (#13557438)
>At Forbes, one contributor wrote that the book “may help explain the otherwise inexplicable”.

It's only inexplicable if you live in a coastal bubble where everyone thinks the same way you do. It can't be that your values were rejected by people you deride in "flyover country" (and still not by a majority of the country). No, it must be that they've been brainwashed by television!

But somehow the purveyors of this theory have remained untouched by the corrupting influence of mass media.

Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by flukus on Thursday February 02, 2017 @10:39PM (#13557468)
To add to this, I bet most people here would think that the immigration changes are universally loathed, but most Americans support them:

http://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-trump-immigration-poll...

Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by pasbesoin on Friday February 03, 2017 @03:50PM (#13563183)
Other than flat panel TV's and cell phones, a lot of people in "middle America" have gotten absolutely shit out of the last 20 - 30 years. Work's more for less and no advancement. The future is ever more uncertain. Healthcare's gone from expensive to unachievable. Illegal immigration has produced considerable downward pressure on lower-end jobs as well as non-wage benefits (illegals have no leverage with respect to benefits, and this places additional pressure on everyone else to give up on them).

My cousin's little old farm town in the middle of Nebraska has become significantly "hispanified." And while many of them are nice enough, a significant fraction are not. Regardless, it has produced a very significant, dramatic local social and cultural shift. Which many remaining voters find quite disruptive.

Republican as well as Democratic "internationalists" turned their backs on these potential voters and with varying forms of rhetoric about "the greater good."

Well, there's only so much personal sacrifice people are going to put up with.

Trump... well, whatever you think about truth and falsehood with respect to him and the people immediately around him (campaign, advisors, talking heads, opportunists, hangers-on... oh, and his family), he gave this demographic a message to vote for.

In the U.S., social cohesion has always been limited and reinforced significantly through force and intimidation rather than cooperation. But, in a politically significant while not / no longer economically and popularly dominant demographic, it wore thin enough to engender this disruption.

The "internationalists" forgot the first rule of politics and of social stability: To take care of your own. Well, they came to mis-identify "their own" in terms of their personal economic benefit as opposed to the polities they formally represented.

Having watched my own little economic sector, tech., get run over by outsourcing and ageism, I have very little sympathy for them nor for the economic friends they thought they were representing.

P.S. I'm no Trump supporter. I'm simply saying, neither am I surprised by what's happened. Except, perhaps, than he actually achieved the Presidency. The Clinton camp and the DNC can hang that one squarely around their necks.

P.P.S. I'm not particularly defending the Trump voter, either. A lot of nastiness and short-sightedness and myopic self-interest in that camp, too. Nonetheless, they are voters -- members of society -- and trying to quietly flush them down the drain was not a particularly astute political strategy.

P.P.P.S. There is also another -- and perhaps the dominant -- side to Trump support: People who believe simply that you get what you deserve. Regardless of circumstances. They are doing ok -- well, even. And that they entirely deserve credit for that. Anyone else? Not their problem. And if the other person's circumstances leave them down and out: Well, they deserve that.

Some of these people: They will take and take. I experienced this personally, this past year, trying to help one of them out of difficult straights. As their circumstances improved -- not insignificantly through considerable dint of effort on my part -- they became less grateful rather than more, and a criticism of others that I thought they were initially beginning to see past, returned in full force.

Direct kindness ultimately had no influence on their perspective and behavior -- no matter what words and attitudes they used to initially solicit and gain support.

And THIS really scares me, more than a bit. Or divests me somewhat more of my own apparently mistaken ideals.

Some of these people, are simply intractable. There is no compromise with them, no coming to a mutual understanding.

Were the "internationalists" right, simply to try to leave them behind? No -- even if they are intractable, simply ignoring them is short-sighted, in its own fashion.

Anyway, I've glued enough P.S.'s onto this comment that reflects my continuing struggle to find my own way through these set of personalities written wholesale onto our current politics.

Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by angersock on Friday February 03, 2017 @05:32PM (#13563938)
Thank you for your writeup; it was thoughtful and well-phrased.
Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by HoppedUpMenace on Thursday February 02, 2017 @07:56PM (#13556666)
Isn't this article purely an opinion piece? I don't mind, but if it is, it should be labeled as such and not passed off as investigative journalism. That being said, you could argue that its both or any number of things, for example:

news supression/distortion -> Orwell

class system of superiors/inferiors -> Brave New World

Could even possibly throw Citizen Kane into the mix but that may be a stretch.

Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by norea-armozel on Friday February 03, 2017 @11:41AM (#13561042)
So Brazil minus the ducts?
Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by tronreg on Thursday February 02, 2017 @08:10PM (#13556759)
"the average weekly screen time for an American adult – brace yourself; this is not a typo – is 74 hours"
Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by jamesmcintyre on Thursday February 02, 2017 @08:54PM (#13556981)
Throughout this entire election and transition I've been wondering if Neil Postman's son is going to remind people of his father's warning in "Amusing Ourselves to Death". It's truly surreal that this detailed prediction I read years ago, written two years before I was born, has been playing out in such a spectacularly... real way. There's this feeling you get when you understand what we're in the grips of yet you also observe and experience just how overwhelmingly impossible it is for everyone to confront the same realizations in order for us to course-correct and avoid what increasingly feels like an inevitable disaster.

Neil Postman was both somewhat deterministic in his beliefs about our future and then reluctantly optimistic when pushed. In an interview he jokingly qualified his optimistic statement with "but remember I'm an American which means I'm eternally optimistic". I think he was also very struck with this feeling, that it is all so clear what is happening yet the dance continues and to warn people, to educate, to improve things in a systemic way that'd be sufficient enough in capacity to combat these omnipresent machinations is so overwhelmingly difficult and complex that one feels a bit hopeless.

In that same interview he said "..to the extent that there would be a serious conversation among Americans about these issues I think we could pull through." (Link to end of interview: https://youtu.be/FRabb6_Gr2Y?t=27m)

Because this problem is so complex and deeply-entrenched in so many facets of our existence whatever course-correction can be made will have to be the result of a phenomenon which I'd describe as very much "emergent". And that phenomenon will be an amalgamation of shifts in thought and behavior spanning all facets of culture and society. You could say "organic movement" but I am not even so hopeful as to think one or a few "organic" movements would suffice. I believe the shift would have to be systemic but also cultural, only a shift in our beliefs- in what our culture deems valuable would provide enough motivation to re-center ourselves around a new definition of civic duty.

Ever since I wanted to be a web developer my dream was to start a successful startup that would allow me to then fund the development of a web technology, likely a platform of some sort, that would help solve some of these bewilderingly complex problems primarily rooted in education. I am always trying to think of how a web technology could fit into the puzzle.

However, if a the American people do not start a discussion about this problem (not one facet of the problem like "fake news" but an acknowledgement of it's deeply-entrenched, multi-faceted nature) than we cannot give it a name and fight it. We cannot begin to plan solutions if we do not first have most people on board which the fact that the problem exists in the first place.

If you've read this far maybe you too are interested in this problem and maybe a couple web developers slowly ideating and iterating over time could be a valuable contribution? Feel free to hit me up: james.checks.his.email at gmail dot com.

*edited to add link to interview.

[dead]
Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by myowncrapulence on Thursday February 02, 2017 @07:38PM (#13556552)

  And the funny thing is? This post is going to be rank-banned and thrown at the bottom of this comment section. Sure, upvote the submission here, but don't be blind to the glaring hypocrisy of the site you're doing it on.
From the Hacker News comments guidelines:

"Avoid gratuitous negativity."

"Please resist commenting about being downvoted. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading."

"Please don't bait other users by inviting them to downvote you or proclaim that you expect to get downvoted. "

You're yelling at no one. You'd do better to get attention for your cause by not treating everyone on this site like a demon.

Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by thtoesubd on Thursday February 02, 2017 @08:20PM (#13556820)
Pish posh.

HN mods regularly violate their own guidelines, play favorites, and outright ban views they find unsettling.

Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by applecrazy on Thursday February 02, 2017 @06:14PM (#13555901)
Well said, you get an upvote. I completely agree but I think your tone will be unappreciated by many here on HN.

But in all honesty, don't you think each book predicted a different aspect of our lives? For example, 1984 describes the government while F451 describes the sentiment of the crowds, and finally Brave New World describes our behavior as a society.

Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by pc2g4d on Thursday February 02, 2017 @06:41PM (#13556141)
I did downvote you, because you wrapped your meaningful contribution ("don't forget Fahrenheit 451") in insults.
Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by multinglets on Thursday February 02, 2017 @07:00PM (#13556304)
I did upvote him, because your downvote deserves to be canceled because that is stupid.
Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by malynda on Thursday February 02, 2017 @07:42PM (#13556583)
Do you have any more intelligent response than "because that is stupid"? Yes, a good point was made. But, also, let's try to remember to maintain some level of professionalism here! If you want to troll someone, go to Twitter.
Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by thtoesubd on Thursday February 02, 2017 @08:22PM (#13556829)
It's well established in multiple threads that people downvote and flag views they find unacceptable and has nothing to do with guidelines.
Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by grzm on Thursday February 02, 2017 @08:31PM (#13556876)
The world will always include bad actors. That doesn't mean we should encourage or tolerate bad behavior.
Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by thtoesubd on Thursday February 02, 2017 @08:51PM (#13556965)
Whatever gets you through the night.

HN commenters are turning this place into another safe space. Contrary views are not tolerated.

Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by grzm on Thursday February 02, 2017 @09:08PM (#13557035)
Considering the animated discussions from a wide variety of positions, I'm not seeing what you are. I do see strong bias against overly aggressive and uncivil behavior. I also see a few members who have a hard time seeing beyond their own bias. It's natural to be more aware of behavior against your own "side". It's just one of our cognitive biases we need to be aware of and guard against.

Comment and submission data is available via the HN APIs. Put together an analysis and share your methodology and results. Regardless of your findings, I know I'd be interested in seeing them. I'm sure a lot of other HN members would be, too.

Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by dodjodjd on Thursday February 02, 2017 @09:51PM (#13557269)
Are you even reading? Some posts are not even allowed to be listed by the mods here. They don't show up dead, they just don't show up at all.
Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by grzm on Thursday February 02, 2017 @10:12PM (#13557347)
I pay pretty close attention. I browse with showdead on. Can you clarify what you mean by "don't show up at all"? Posts by banned users are dead as soon as they're posted, but I think you mean something else. Do you have a couple of examples of what you're talking about?
Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by angersock on Friday February 03, 2017 @05:22PM (#13563866)
Mods will occasionally detach subthreads, and have even been known to remove them from a story.

As one might imagine, a subthread without even a story parent is basically inaccessible unless you know its precise ID.

Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by sctb on Friday February 03, 2017 @06:22PM (#13564249)
Well it's not known to me. What makes you say that? We don't delete comments or posts like this, but if you know of specific cases we can certainly take a look.
Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by angersock on Friday February 03, 2017 @07:21PM (#13564639)
You...do appreciate the difficulty in finding these instances if they weren't bookmarked at the time, right? Also, just how silly it is to have the alleged censors say "Oh, well, that's news to me--can you find examples of the things we memoryholed?"

It might help if you folks kept a public moderation log.

Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by sctb on Friday February 03, 2017 @08:01PM (#13564879)
I don't think it's unfair to ask someone to back up a claim, especially when the dataset is publicly available through the API or (more conveniently) in BigQuery:

  SELECT count(*) FROM [bigquery-public-data:hacker_news.comments] 
  WHERE parent IS NULL;
Story and comment IDs are also simply incrementing integers. We're not making it easy on ourselves to hide this sort of thing!
Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by angersock on Friday February 03, 2017 @09:45PM (#13565339)
Oh nifty. When did you all add that stuff to BigQuery? The Firebase API suggests that that dataset is going away in like a month.
Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by projektir on Thursday February 02, 2017 @08:16PM (#13556798)
I don't see you actually arguing your point, beyond a heavy dose of pathos. The reason this kind of approach gets downvoted is that you're replacing any sort of argumentation by just trying to attack the issue on an emotional level, and a very manipulative one at that ("people who don't agree with me are uncritical hypocrites").

I don't know if it's terribly useful to argue which book is more relevant. There seems to be some truth in all of them, but then also a lot of assumptions and unfounded claims, and they all honestly feel very dated. I think I've seen a lot of the same ideas better expressed on blogs.

My preferred author is actually McLuhan. If we're going to talk about TV's, the internet, and social media, I think he covered that whole subject a lot better, and with a much more interesting point than "people suck": that technology can have effects we cannot predict, and that we're letting reality shape us as opposed to us shaping it. "We shape our tools and afterwards our tools shape us."

We're currently in a time where any sort of philosophy that implies large systemic effects that override will is rather unpalatable (talk about avoiding controversy) to most people, but that's not an assumption we can buy on faith if we want to talk about how and why things are.

The first thing that really needs to be proven in all these sorts of discussions is whether or not the development is somehow unique and extra-bad. I'm not convinced that the current state is so much worse (for whom?) than a time when certain minorities had to deal with more than having their toes stepped on. I really don't know what to do with that statement since the two things are very related. We were huge dicks to certain minorities for millennia. We're now trying to be considerate, and perhaps overdoing it. But what do you propose, not doing it? Maybe this avoiding stepping on toes is a sign of something else, something bigger, something older?

Or was that not the point? Unfortunately, you haven't clearly stated yours, you just quoted an author.

Yeah, people get offended. They get lazy. They live in ways that are not fashionable. When is somebody going to ask why? "People suck" is such a lazy (haha), boring answer, it's a nonanswer. People haven't magically changed, why do they "suck" all the time? Anyone want to answer that?

I don't think anyone wants to, since the answer is rather grim, and it doesn't have anything to do with minorities.

Re:It's Not Orwell, It's Brave New World by jameskegel on Thursday February 02, 2017 @07:19PM (#13556415)
You make a good point.