News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Secret docs reveal: an FBI with vast hidden powers by AnthonyMouse on Thursday February 02, 2017 @03:23PM (#13554278)
> If I tax you at 50% on $500k and 10% on anything under $500k, the relative value of $500,001 vs. $500,000 is ~$.40.

It's $.50, because $500,001 is more than $500,000 and you're taxing anything over $500,000 at 50%.

> -$30,000 :: 50% Tax Rate (to quickly recover the UBI on the first $60k)

> -$132,000 :: 30% Tax Rate (we are no longer recovering UBI, up to $500k)

> -$300,000 :: 60% Tax Rate (to discourage excessive compensation)

You don't need this and you don't want it. You have people making $200K paying a lower marginal tax rate than people making $20K. That makes no sense and is anti-progressive. Your highest tax bracket is more than 20% higher than the existing one (and really 40% higher vs. the long term capital gains rate), but you don't need that money unless you want to pay for a higher UBI, and if you did then you could just use a 60% flat tax rate and let the higher UBI make up for it.

Just use a flat tax with a UBI. All of the complexity really is completely unnecessary.

Also, if you have a UBI you don't need a minimum wage.

> The cheating comes from the itemized deduction process.

The cheating comes from not treating similar transactions the same. Part of that is all the deductions, but part of it is that two different people can make the same dollar and pay a different tax rate. So then you get families cheating because dad makes $240K from the family business and the three children are off at college making nothing, so instead they all get nominal jobs in the family business making $60K each and dad is down to $60K and out of the high tax brackets. And so on with a hundred other ways to redistribute income within a family/corporate hierarchy/whatever to arbitrage non-uniform tax rates.

If there is only one tax rate you can't do any of that.

> The points of vulnerability to this approach also exist in a flat-consumption tax model. (i.e. Someone has to collect the tax on behalf of the government and nothing stops them from lying about their income other than criminal penalties)

VAT solves this easily. Every time a business sells something it has to submit VAT and can only deduct the VAT collected by its suppliers if they actually paid it, so now you have every link in the supply chain with a financial incentive to report the others if they haven't paid.

There are no comments on this comment yet.