Re:Comcast will treat Rokus like CableCARDs, not set-top boxes
by technofiend on Thursday February 02, 2017 @03:31PM
(#13554355)
>I've looked into this before, and TiVo is the ONLY device that accepts CableCard
Silicondust would like a word, sir: https://www.silicondust.com/product/hdhomerun-prime/
>Everything else is a PC-required tuner, which is not same.
"HDHomeRun streams to DLNA compatible devices on your network" - HD Homerun Prime website
Re:Comcast will treat Rokus like CableCARDs, not set-top boxes
by vinhboy on Thursday February 02, 2017 @04:51PM
(#13555079)
Nope not the same. This, like all the other products, is a NETWORK tuner. Meaning, the signal comes out to a cat5. So you need a "PC" to receive the signal.
The TiVo has a HDMI-out, so you can hook it directly to your TV.
Re:Comcast will treat Rokus like CableCARDs, not set-top boxes
by bdavisx on Thursday February 02, 2017 @03:51PM
(#13554533)
But if you want to watch something that's DRM'd (like HBO), the HDHomeRun will only work with a few devices when it comes to watching the video.
Re:Comcast will treat Rokus like CableCARDs, not set-top boxes
by technofiend on Thursday February 02, 2017 @04:40PM
(#13554956)
Yeah, sadly there are limitations on "protected" channels and the FCC seems to be moving away from forcing a consistent and open set top box model. I just punted and cancelled cable altogether. I should probably sell that HDHomeRun Prime I have sitting around collecting dust. LOL.
Re:Comcast will treat Rokus like CableCARDs, not set-top boxes
by gm-conspiracy on Thursday February 02, 2017 @03:56PM
(#13554583)
Oh, so you are not allowed to receive the channel you are paying for?
Re:Comcast will treat Rokus like CableCARDs, not set-top boxes
by technofiend on Thursday February 02, 2017 @05:06PM
(#13555234)
Looks like you can on an XBOX One - https://forum.silicondust.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=119&t=63...
Re:Comcast will treat Rokus like CableCARDs, not set-top boxes
by starnixgod on Thursday February 02, 2017 @03:24PM
(#13554289)
There is the HDHomeRun Prime[1] that will accept a CableCARD and output to any connected device on your network.
I've looked into this before, and TiVo is the ONLY device that accepts CableCard and output to HDMI. There is no competition. Everything else is a tuner, that outputs to your network, which is not same because it requires a PC to receive the signal.
I have a used, non-subscription, TiVo box that allows me to watch Comcast TV through a CableCard. The benefit is that I can watch local channels in HD through the TiVo. If I used a Comcast box, I'd have to pay extra for HD programming and an HD box.
I guess this Roku app would now be an alternative to that hack.