News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by dragonwriter on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:06PM (#13552133)
There is already a consequence to lying as a witness, it's called perjury prosecution.

It's unfortunately infrequently pursued when the perjury occurs in a civil case, but if you want to agitate for consequences, agitate for prosecutors willing to enforce the law.

(Or for a civil cause of action for perjury, but that would have to be carefully crafted to prevent an infinite regress of lawsuits.)

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by bitexploder on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:10PM (#13552170)
That is John's point, though, that you don't have to lie. You can use non-scientific abstraction and obfuscation to testify any way you want. Sort of the post-modern interpretation theory where anything is true, as long as your truth is told more charismatically. This seems pretty obviously true to me.

It probably isn't even perjury. Even the law has some room for interpretation. That is the whole point of case history. Technology is so new and fluid that the legal system may never catch up to or well define the things a crafty obfuscator (expert witness or lawyer) can sling out.

Skilled practitioners in the area of science or engineering will immediately identify the obfuscation and unreality of it, but that does not make it perjury, which does have a much more specific and well defined case law meaning.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by GlennS on Thursday February 02, 2017 @02:12PM (#13553508)
What are the actual requirements for a perjury conviction in the USA? Does the witness have to be intentionally lying? Presumably you don't prosecute someone for being mistaken, misguided or over-confident in their own abilities?

It doesn't sound like Carmack was accusing the witness of lying, but rather they they believed a bit too much in their own pet theory about how to detect copying in code.

I don't usually like to comment on trials, but I think perhaps he has a point here. If there were a reliable method for detecting 'non-literal copying' of code, then the person who made it should be making a killing by selling refactoring tools.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by 1024core on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:11PM (#13552173)
> There is already a consequence to lying as a witness, it's called perjury prosecution.

Except that this is an "expert witness", and not a regular witness. The expert witness offers his/her opinions.

Re:John Carmack on expert witnesses and 'non literal' copying by dragonwriter on Thursday February 02, 2017 @12:17PM (#13552242)
A statement about one's own opinion can be materially false, and provably (in the sense the word applies in the legal system) so.

Certainly, an attorney can (and this is true of any witness, not just expert witness) coordinate with a witness on a line of questioning which carefully avoids any questions where perjury would be necessary to avoid damaging the case. That's why we have witnesses subject to examinstion by opposing counsel, as well.