My suggestion/request would be to just have SE post a request request for proposal to replace A51 on the main SE blog, since SE has had years to do so, has not, and positive the community would find a better solution.
As such, the core philosophy (and bulk of the code) behind it is still more or less the same, but how proposals actually behave has changed dramatically.
We've also made significant changes to the lifecycle of sites after they're created, which you can find discussed on Meta Stack Exchange:
- https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/260754/feedback-req...
- http://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/283663/its-been-a-ye...
All and all, this was one of many reasons I left, the largest being that communities in my opinion should be based around tags, not verticals; tags are in fact in my opinion how SO is run.
Again, thanks, and good luck!
Area 52 has been on hold for years: http://discuss.area51.stackexchange.com/questions/5089/next-...
Robert knows Area 51 isn't working, but given there's no other way to launch an SE users use it and SE as a result doesn't replace it because they're not interested in the long tail of active Q&A communities; last I checked, it takes them months, if not years to move a site from beta to live even after the community mets SE's requirements.
Basically, SE changed their past policies to avoid building Area 52 and SE has no idea what a working Area 52 would be.
If you want an SE, you've got to understand how Area 51 works, get all of your ducks in a row, then roll through it and the beta; otherwise your just asking for problems and leaving it up to SE to help, which is problematic.
To me, the more interesting question would be what are the numbers since launch for Area 51's launch funnel; that is from submitting a proposal, de-duplicating it, (etc), site leaves beta.