News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: SECCOMP – A Secure Spreadsheet by smacktoward on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @02:24PM (#13544030)
I agree it's confusing, but from my reading I think they're talking about a different kind of security than what you describe.

It's more like this: you and I have some process we're collaborating on, and we both have an interest in getting accurate outputs from some kind of computation related to that process. But the only way to get really accurate outputs is to feed in proprietary, "secret" data from both your company and mine, and while we both have an interest in those outputs, neither of us wants to share our proprietary data with the other.

This solves that problem by letting us each put our data into our own Excel workbook, mine visible only to me and yours only to you, and then get the output of some mutually-agreed-upon calculation using both of our inputted data, without ever seeing the numbers the other party put into their workbook. So if you and I can agree on formulas that would provide the outputs we want, and I trust you to enter accurate data on your end and you trust me on mine, we can now do a lot of interesting analysis without ever having to open our respective kimonos, as the saying goes (http://www.npr.org/sections/codeswitch/2014/11/02/360479744/...).

I have no idea how well it actually works, or how secure the data flowing between the workbooks actually is. But it's an interesting idea!

Re:Show HN: SECCOMP – A Secure Spreadsheet by na85 on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @04:52PM (#13545664)
>It's more like this: you and I have some process we're collaborating on, and we both have an interest in getting accurate outputs from some kind of computation related to that process. But the only way to get really accurate outputs is to feed in proprietary, "secret" data from both your company and mine, and while we both have an interest in those outputs, neither of us wants to share our proprietary data with the other.

Ahh, that makes a little more sense. Seems like I could get your "secret" data by simply reversing the operation that gives us our shared result, though, doesn't it? Unless it's some kind of modulo type thing.

Re:Show HN: SECCOMP – A Secure Spreadsheet by davidcerezo on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @06:14PM (#13546404)
No, you can't reverse anything. There are more details at: https://www.calctopia.com/2017/02/01/on-the-security-model/
Re:Show HN: SECCOMP – A Secure Spreadsheet by karulont on Thursday February 02, 2017 @09:51AM (#13550859)
In general you are correct, but there are still easy cases where reversing is trivial.

For example if the shared output is the average (AVG = (X1 + X2) / 2). If I know X1 and AVG, I can easily calculate X2 (X2 = AVG * 2 - X1).

However, usually you want to calculate something more interesting, that depends on more variables, so you won't get an exact number on the other parties secret inputs.