Re:Apple Reports Record First Quarter Results
by maxxxxx on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @09:57AM
(#13541156)
I don't think that's true. I don't like the idea of buying a laptop that for some reason is super thin but then I have to carry around adapters. I would much prefer a lot of common adapters built into the device even if it's thicker or heavier. Make the MacBook Air have only USB-C and thin but the "Pro" should be more utilitarian and practical.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Apple Reports Record First Quarter Results
by rayiner on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @10:18AM
(#13541322)
Do you go to a presentation assuming someone will have an HDMI cable handy to plug into the projector? If you do, you're a braver person than I. But I can carry a USB-C to HDMI cable just as easily as a HDMI to HDMI.
At some point, inconvenience to part of the user base has to be outweighed by convenience to everyone else. The new MBP fits a 15" screen into a form factor that is edging in on where 13-14" laptops were not too long ago. The new 13" is edging into where 12" laptops used to be. Given that lots of "pros" and "road warriors" suffer through 12-13" laptops for size/weight reasons, that's a pretty huge benefit that might easily justify the loss of ports for a big segment of the user base.
Re:Apple Reports Record First Quarter Results
by maxxxxx on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @10:40AM
(#13541501)
In my company all projectors have an HDMI cable already so there is no need to carry one. I just think if you need really small go for an Air. With my current MBP I can walk around without adapters and have reasonable confidence that i can deal with most unexpected peripherals like USB devices or HDMI screens. In my view they should have put in a USB-C port but also left at least some legacy ports. My MBP 13 has an SD card reader , screen connector and USB ports and is still pretty small so I don't buy the size argument.
Re:Apple Reports Record First Quarter Results
by rayiner on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @11:43AM
(#13542247)
> My MBP 13 has an SD card reader , screen connector and USB ports and is still pretty small so I don't buy the size argument.
Why'd you get a 13"? If the 15" was close to the same size/weight would you have gotten the 15"?
Re:Apple Reports Record First Quarter Results
by maxxxxx on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @12:24PM
(#13542687)
I think the new 15 is still quite a bit bigger than the older 13. In any case, if some more connectors would have made the new MBP slightly thicker or heavier I would have preferred that. If you want super super thin, buy an Air.