News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by sgt101 on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @05:54PM (#13536187)
I made cyder at home a couple of years ago (about 8 gallons).

I had 2 pints at one sitting, I have no memory of the evening past about 10pm and when I woke up my first thought was that I had had a stroke.

The rest of the stuff is still sitting in the shed.

Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by vidanay on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @06:07PM (#13536320)
I'll tell you a story that happened to me

One day as I went down to Cork by the sea

The sun it was hot and the day it was warm,

Says I a quiet pint wouldn't do me no harm

I went in and I called for a bottle of stout

Says the barman, I'm sorry, all the beer is sold out

Try whiskey or paddy, ten years in the wood

Says I, I'll try cider, I've heard it was good.

Oh never, Oh never, Oh never again

If I live to be a hundred or a hundred and ten

I fell to the ground and I couldn't get up

After drinking a quart of the Johnny Jump Up

http://thebards.net/music/lyrics/Johnny_Jump_Up.shtml

Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by pavel_lishin on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @09:14PM (#13537579)
Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by lightedman on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @06:17PM (#13536393)
You might need to distill off the methanol that might be present, if you're blacking out. Had a similar problem with some homebrew wine where a glass tossed me to blacking out (yet I can toss back a half pint of vodka without too much issue.) Turned out there was a good amount of methanol in there.
Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by mattkrause on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @11:42PM (#13538312)
How sure are you about this?

From what I've read, it is very hard to generate methanol via fermentation alone[0] and home-brew usually has 2-3 ppm, versus a LD_{50} in the tens of thousands of ppm. Obviously, there might be problems well before the LD_{50}, but that's a lot of wiggle room (and methanol would be out-competed by the ethanol which is presumably also in the booze).

[0] Concentrating the wine via freezing (as in some ice wines or applejack) might be an exception to this, but I'm not sure.

Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by lightedman on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @12:46PM (#13542963)
Very sure as I was using naturally-present yeast instead of any brewer's yeast or bread yeast. Methanol content is something to look out for when you use natural yeasts.

Source: 15 years brewing/distilling. Just got lazy/too self-assured one day.

Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by mattkrause on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @01:28PM (#13543426)
Hmmm....

It does look pectin can be degraded into methanol by some microbes. I'm surprised there was enough feedstock to generate a problematic amount of methanol, but I'm glad you're ok.

Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by somberi on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @11:36PM (#13538283)
Hooch / Bootleg alcohol are rife with methanol-related deaths.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_methanol_poisoning_inc...

Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by bbcbasic on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @05:13AM (#13539618)
I always thought that was because methylated spirits were used in place of pure alcohol? I.e. not a fermentation issue.
Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by lightedman on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @12:46PM (#13542976)
Nope. In Mississippi prisons (Did some time myself) we just took OJ and yeast-leavened bread from our lunch trays, sealed it in a plastic bag, and had hooch in a couple days.
Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by civilian on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @06:24PM (#13536446)
I was going to ask sgt101 to send me a galloon of his cyder before I read your comment, hah. Uh yeah, methanol is scary.
Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by nitrogen on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @08:07PM (#13537158)
I've heard third hand rumors of people at fancy parties using sublingual methanol drops recreationally. Sounds insane to me, if true.
Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by moron4hire on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @10:49PM (#13538058)
Or you could just sanitize your filthy carboy before brewing.
Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by lightedman on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @12:47PM (#13542981)
Wrong. Natural yeasts produce methanol in fairly sufficient amounts to cause damage even when mixed with ethanol.
Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by cthalupa on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @03:53PM (#13545030)
Source? I harvest my own wild yeast, order interesting samples from boutique yeast labs, and am involved in communities dedicated to this sort of thing, and as such, have also read mountains of research. All the research I've read, all of the things I've brewed, and all of the people I've spoken to that do this say quite the opposite.

Fruit pectin can be broken down into methanol, but it creates tiny amounts. You're talking like 20 to 200mg per liter.

Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by lightedman on Friday February 03, 2017 @09:38AM (#13560035)
I've been brewing for roughly 15 years, and let me tell you, there are more yeasts than you'll suspect in your batch if you're going with the natural yeast present directly on the grape and nothing else. Plenty of them have zero issues making lots of methanol and if they manage to become the dominant culture, well...

BTW - prison hooch methanol poisonings would like to have a word with you. Even regular bread yeasts will make enough methanol.

Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by moron4hire on Friday February 03, 2017 @09:54AM (#13560135)
That's bacteria, dude, not yeast.
Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by lightedman on Friday February 03, 2017 @10:50AM (#13560591)
Incorrect. Bacteria typically do it with ammonia compounds, not pectins and sugars.

http://homedistiller.org/intro/methanol/methanol

Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by moron4hire on Friday February 03, 2017 @10:59PM (#13565573)
I am not disputing that "some" level of methanol is created by yeast fermentation. But you are not going to get anything approaching a significant amount of methanol out of it, unless you have an infection.

Especially if we're talking about blacking out, as the GP post was saying. If you have enough methanol to be problem, it's because you're equipment is dirty. You'll get more methanol from a week-old jug of orange juice than you will out of making grape wine in warm conditions.

But this is typical of people. You're so quick to gleefully jump and declare someone "WRONG!" that they don't take a moment to figure out if their evidence even means anything. It's why I can't stand being on most programming or brewing forums anymore. Folks like you ruin it.

Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by lightedman on Saturday February 04, 2017 @12:00PM (#13567696)
"Especially if we're talking about blacking out, as the GP post was saying. If you have enough methanol to be problem, it's because you're equipment is dirty."

No, as I buy brand new carboys every time. PET 3-gallon bottles are had for like 5 bucks each and I just give them to someone else to sterilize and use in their water cooler when I'm done making a batch of wine.

Here's why I get methanol - A. high natural yeast concentration. B. Raw unfiltered mash - the grapes have had a gentle sterilizing soak in 300 ppm cold bleach water solution for 60 seconds. This wipes out most bacteria but leaves the natural yeasts mostly untouched (the haze on grapes resists lower concentrations of bleach.) This means I have tons of pectins as I'm not fermenting filtered juice like most people would when making wine, I ferment the entire thing to get maximum flavor profile (and you can't obtain such a natural blush otherwise.)

Fifteen years of doing it. I have my brewer's certifcation and used to work for (ugh) Coors.

Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by 3chelon on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @08:08AM (#13540397)
I make cider every year and I've never had any problems - I think it's the easiest form of alcohol to make.

On the question of methanol, it is my understanding it comes from the high pectin content. I always use a pectic enzyme to break down the pectin, mainly because that releases more sugars and makes the cider clearer, but possibly it helps stop methanol formation? I know it can be an issue if you distill cider into apple brandy (calvados) - but that's illegal in the UK anyway without a license, so has never been an issue.

Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by david-given on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @05:15AM (#13539625)
Friend of mine's family made something which they called 'apple wine': an open bucket with sugar, apple juice, some citrus (lemon juice, I believe) and then left for about a week. (With muslin over the top to keep the flies off!)

Wild yeast causes it to start fermenting. Once it begins to froth, you bottle. After another week or so it's lightly carbonated and very slightly alcoholic.

The thing is, it continues to ferment in the bottles. So as time passes, it gets more and more alcoholic and less and less sweet, as the yeast consumes the sugar. So while the children were allowed to drink it for the first few weeks after bottling, after a certain point it was distinctly adults-only. So it's quite possible that the parent simply left theirs to ferment too long.

...I used to make ginger beer, which is a variation on the same thing; you cultivate a yeast/bacteria/ginger culture used for the fermentation rather than relying on wild yeast, but the process is the same. Thing about ginger beer, though, is that it's heavily flavoured with ginger, and you need the sugar to make it drinkable. So if you left it for too long it ended up both extremely alcoholic and mouth-puckeringly bitter.

(I can strongly recommend giving ginger beer a try, actually. It's dead easy to make, exceedingly nice, you can pick any alcohol level you like including almost none, and is a continuation of a thoroughly ancient tradition. Be warned, though: (a) it's packed full of sugar, (b) it's quite hard to make in small quantities, and (c) if you get the bug you may find yourself surreptitiously exchanging jam-jars full of biological slime at pubs with total strangers...)

Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by sgt101 on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @07:37AM (#13540217)
I think my issue was/is two fold.

1) I think that the wild yeast in my orchard is a bit "oomphy" 2) I put 8 grams of sugar a pint in for the brew. Which was far too much.

Next year I should have a decent harvest to go at (I've changed out my apple trees and the new ones put in five years ago are fruiting nicely now) so I'm going to have another go... at 4 grams a pint.

Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by teddyknox on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @07:56PM (#13537089)
Lucky you didn't go blind
Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by a_t48 on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @09:32PM (#13537666)
I'm sure you can find someone to take it off your hands (possible methanol aside...)
Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by sgt101 on Wednesday February 01, 2017 @07:35AM (#13540190)
I'm going to use it as weedkiller.
Re:Were Early Modern People Perpetually Drunk? (2016) by dsfyu404ed on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @11:46PM (#13538331)
If you need someone to get rid of it I'll take it off your hands.