Re:One Percent Stake
by superquest on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @06:17AM
(#13529621)
> Which of the above is the author advocating for?
Exactly.
The points were valid up until this point, but the question begged by the title "one percent stake" is never answered.
Perhaps the article was created to provoke conversation about an issue, rather than to solutionise it.
I think the main point trying to be conveyed is that "risk" entitles reward is false, and that others should share in the reward. I agree in part, and that's what a decent and fair salary is for. The author puts forward similar ideas about her own company.
But she's attacking a straw man. The quote specifically only discusses equity, not salary. Removing the bits about equity would lead to a better more coherent article in my opinion.
Re:One Percent Stake
by superquest on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @07:40AM
(#13529999)
Well it's clearly the former!
But as for the latter, why do they mention their own company in a way that implies their equity policies are more enlightened if they're not "solutionising"?
> I'll never have this equity policy at my company. I'll never tell someone that they deserve a less comfortable life because they have already have a less comfortable life.
1. Founder takes 100%, no one else gets anything.
2. Everyone that joins gets an equal share, which approaches a minuscule amount as more people join.
3. Some people get more than others. Some get none.
Which of the above is the author advocating for? There's no actual follow up on what the author would do with regards to equity. She only speaks about salary.
> That means paying juniors very well, paying late stage employees well and fairly. It means treating people as humans.
I wholeheartedly agree with this statement, but it has nothing to do with the original quote the article was written about.