It's a small world. :)
As a long time user of hackpad, it's nothing more than a glorified document editor, and very simple at that, with meagre "shared editing" capabilities that we've had for decades, even in desktop apps.
(The main reason I stuck with it is it's faster to load than Google Docs, and I only care about basic editing).
At a certain level I wonder if this, like Google X, isn't more a recruiting tool than an actual product. Something to say "we do sexy things here".
It was the cumbersome Web interface that was the main problem, rather (the execution) rather than the concept.
The UI was clunky and the epitome of what happens when programmers design. Everything was jam packed into the screen so that it was immediately obvious what kinds of things you could do or how to go about what you wanted to do. It introduced a lot of concepts all at once, causing an unnecessary learning curve.
The spiritual successor was OpenSocial gadgets, also now gone except in some corporate spaces.
s/Wave/Paper in this Wave obituary from 2010:
> Wave brought together elements of instant messaging, e-mail, microblogging, and collaborative editing in a single service that strongly emphasized concurrency and rich media. ... Despite its prodigious sophistication under the hood, the service never resonated with its target audience. Regular end users saw it as a mismatched amalgamation of disparate messaging paradigms blended together in a cumbersome Web-based interface.
https://arstechnica.com/business/2010/08/wave-cancellation-g...