News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Camus and Sartre split up over the question of how to... by pmoriarty on Monday January 30, 2017 @02:48PM (#13524375)
You have to remember that these were two French intellectuals, debating in a country, culture, and time period where Socialism vs Communism was very much a live issue.

That's not really true in the United States today, where even Socialism is generally held in contempt, and Communism is considered to be a demonstratably failed ideology which doesn't even deserve to be taken seriously.

On top of this, intellectualism itself is viewed with great suspicion by many Americans, who much prefer to hear celebrity gossip, or watch sports and reality shows. As a result, the "public" intellectual debates of the era are dumbed down and infotainmentized by a media mostly concerned with ratings and pandering to the lowest common denominator.

There still are plenty of debates in academia in the United States today, but they're not very public, and mostly take place in academic journals which most of the public would rather die before reading.

I've heard that France is still a culture that greatly respects their intellectuals, so I would expect they still have many public intellectual debates these days. Maybe someone who keeps current with them could comment.

Re:How Camus and Sartre split up over the question of how to... by wahern on Monday January 30, 2017 @04:24PM (#13525170)
I agree with everything you said. But I'd suggest that not only are the debates in academia alive, they're actually too vigorous and too radical.

I think one of the contributors to the current political situation is the increasing influence of academia on politics and the law. Instead of having a few big ideas that we wrestle with, every politician and lawyer is a little Leninist bent on burning everything down in favor of their ever-changing pet political philosophies. And the notion of moderation has somehow become radicalized, I think; a dirty word for some people and a rallying cry for others.

The vigorous creativity of scholarship provides an endless supply of fodder in terms of new ideas, new reasoning, new justifications, and most recently new "facts". If we were a nation of philosophers it'd be some kind of paradise. But we're not, and it's ripping apart our core social institutions.

I'm not dissing the scholarship, or trying to suggest it's all bunk. I mean, even bunk can be valuable by challenging assumptions or by making conspicuous assumptions itself. But too much of that debate is bleeding out into the culture. A whole new layer of public policy institutions and media outlets feeds off and disseminates the half-baked ideas. There's never any time or energy to winnow the chaff. And so it's effectively poisoning the social and political culture.

Re:How Camus and Sartre split up over the question of how to... by pm90 on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:50PM (#13525848)
I don't think it is as fragmented as you explain it to be. There has been a broad agreement that the principles of the New Deal work; they have worked before and they would work now. However, there has been a deliberate effort by (a few) of the ultra-rich to subvert New Deal policies and this has been done through the creation and continued funding of institutions dedicated to what Krugman calls "movement conservatism". I would suggest 2 books: "Dark Money" and "Conscience of a Liberal" to get a better idea of the world that we operate in right now.
Re:How Camus and Sartre split up over the question of how to... by ZenoArrow on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:29PM (#13525686)
>"A whole new layer of public policy institutions and media outlets feeds off and disseminates the half-baked ideas. There's never any time or energy to winnow the chaff. And so it's effectively poisoning the social and political culture."

Can you name one cultural meme that's emerged from academia in the last 10 years? I certainly can't. I simply don't think academic debates have that great a cultural impact in our modern society, regardless of this increased vigor you're referring to.

On the other hand, I can think of recent cultural memes that have emerged from the political sphere, pushed by a diverse range of people (from corporate interests to grass roots activists). Very few politically active people seem to be waiting around for answers from academia, they've got their own agendas to push.

Re:How Camus and Sartre split up over the question of how to... by pm90 on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:53PM (#13525860)
Cultural memes aren't really the measure of progress, or worth, of academia. And "academia" itself is a pretty broad term: are you referring to Philosophy, or the Social Sciences or what?
Re:How Camus and Sartre split up over the question of how to... by ZenoArrow on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @02:16AM (#13528466)
>"Cultural memes aren't really the measure of progress, or worth, of academia."

I didn't say they were a measure of the worth of academia. However, they are a way to track the evolution of public debate. For example, the '1%' meme (about the top 1% owning more than the remaining 99%) has shaped public debate around wealth inequality. If academia has been a big influence on public debate, my argument is that we should see this play out in cultural memes. Cultural memes are just ideas which are commonly known in our shared culture. The GP indicated that the restlessness of academia was damaging public debate, my argument was that the general public was largely indifferent to this activity.

Re:How Camus and Sartre split up over the question of how to... by wahern on Monday January 30, 2017 @07:43PM (#13526470)
At the core of earnest arguments behind climate change denialism are legitimate studies and critiques of not only climate science, but of modern modeling and statistical analysis techniques. A core underlying meme would be "lies, damn lies, and statistics". And more technical one would be "overfitting".

Those critiques are necessary and valid and healthy, but only in the realm of professional discourse. As they leaked out they lost all context and contingency and infused our culture with an unhealthy distrust and skepticism of the legitimacy of scientific claims and techniques.

The concept of regulatory capture has been co-opted by conservatives as an excuse to oppose any sort of government regulation, even though the theory of regulatory capture doesn't make specific claims about the benefit or value or appropriateness of regulation. That concept is not as widely known popularly but still very widely abused far outside the academic realm. It's increasingly being adopted by liberals to unfairly criticize sensible cooperation between regulatory agencies and private business.

The Laffer Curve is similar that way, except that absurdly Arthur Laffer was the first person to claim (and continues to claim) the concept proves things it doesn't.

On the liberal side we can look at trigger warnings and micro-aggressions. The original academic debates that coined those terms were, IMO, quite legitimate and important. In 2017 is it really controversial to think that we might want to give some thought to people suffering from PTSD, such as when discussing rape in the presence of possibly unknown rape victims still feeling victimized. And the concept of micro-aggression is genius. It finally gave us a concrete, if limited, framework for discussing and addressing many of the subtle ways that our inherent cultural biases prejudice and harm people. But both ideas were co-opted and prematurely expanded and radically applied by an overly eager student movement.

There are countless others, too. They abound everywhere. Every editorial article floweths over with inappropriate citations to complex academic theories. It's like the popular psychology fad of the 1950s ballooned to encompass every field, and we all have the fever. We're all pseudo-scientists, now, credentialed to apply scientific theory, and defend ourselves with scientific theory, however we see fit. It's not new. Social darwinism is a classic example of the abuse of science by both scientists and laymen. It just seems more common and more pervasive.

Maybe I'm mistaken in thinking that the pace of radicalism was slower earlier last century and in times prior. Part of the reason I think that is because college attendance rates are way up, which I think implies that a large portion of society has been exposed to more radical and more highly technical ideas. And like the advent of cheap sugar, we've developed a taste for new, sweet ideas that's messing with our political chemistry. But maybe that's also a poor assumption, not to mention a poor analogy.

Re:How Camus and Sartre split up over the question of how to... by ZenoArrow on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @02:49AM (#13528587)
Some good examples, thank you.

Taking one example...

"Social darwinism is a classic example of the abuse of science by both scientists and laymen. It just seems more common and more pervasive."

Perhaps this sort of misunderstanding arises as there's a layer of abstraction between scientific inquiry and the results that are produced. The layman only sees the conclusions, not the subtleties and caveats that are part of the wider truth. Social darwinism seems to be an example of what happens when knowledge loses its original context. I suspect it's common as humans seek to find patterns in the world around them. The problem comes when people find patterns backed up from a source perceived to have greater authority, as it has a chilling effect on further exploration.

Re:How Camus and Sartre split up over the question of how to... by enqk on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:31PM (#13524724)
It is quite illuminating to see the exchange for instance between Michel Foucault and Noam Chomsky to get a sense of the difference of tone and focus between european and american intellectuals.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3wfNl2L0Gf8

Re:How Camus and Sartre split up over the question of how to... by mlmlmasd on Monday January 30, 2017 @03:57PM (#13524920)
What difference in tone and focus are you referring to? Noam Chomsky seems like a much more 'European-style' (academic?) intellectual then the pop/celeb 'intellectuals' popular in America such as Sam Harris, Christopher Hitchens, etc.
Re:How Camus and Sartre split up over the question of how to... by fspear on Monday January 30, 2017 @05:45PM (#13525815)
>On top of this, intellectualism itself is viewed with great suspicion by many Americans, who much prefer to hear celebrity gossip, or watch sports and reality shows. As a result, the "public" intellectual debates of the era are dumbed down and infotainmentized by a media mostly concerned with ratings and pandering to the lowest common denominator.

What a brave new world we live in...

Re:How Camus and Sartre split up over the question of how to... by defen on Tuesday January 31, 2017 @12:02AM (#13527816)
It's not really new...Richard Hofstadter won a Pulitzer Prize in 1964 for Anti-intellectualism in American Life wherein he argued that it was fundamentally embedded into the American character due to the democratization of education and our evangelical Protestant heritage.