At least personally, I feel it worked pretty well... but there was a drop in quality when they introduced probations (a temp ban), meaning breaking the rules stopped hurting your wallet (you could get back in as long as you paid, and didn't do something so bad you got a permaban)
In what year do you feel the Internet was better than it is now?
There's no clear point, but when it was loosely "reserved" to a certain "elite" (financial, technical, cultural, scientific) which showed genuine interest in it, it was in a much better condition than now. It sounds terrible to say that, but as the masses joined in, the media dumbed down and what it carries dumbed down as well. Another step towards dumbness happened when kids were massively allowed to enter the arena. Again, this sounds harsh, but that's the pitiful reality of humankind. And businesses and capitalism know very well how to encourage the most vile behaviours in order to make more profit.
It also shifted from a confidence & collaboration mode to insecurity & defiance. Now it's "oh my God how this protocol / library is insecure, how could one design such a stupid thing?" Well, I am not sure who is most stupid.
Remember when a 'troll' was just someone who was just pulling a prank teasing a few other people? Well now the same word means a stupid, racist, hateful, mean guy who drowns out a forum or a site with his feces and whose attacks impact real life of its victims.
Which brings me to tell that another big difference is that when Internet was disconnected from real life, it was much better. That was a big turning point too. You used to be able to write everything under your real name and not fear some acquaintance, school mate, employer or any other peeping Tom or enemy would search for it.
So there's not a single year to point out, but during the last 15 (20?) years a series of steps gradually turned Internet in the shithole (and supermarket) it is now. And none of those steps was positive.
I'm not sure it's got worse intrinsically, but it has certainly got larger, so the badness has scaled along with it.
The problem is one of "lawlessness"; adhoc reprisals from your fellow netizens aren't an improvement.
This has led to walled-in gardens, where the noise is amplified. I'd even tentatively argue it's because having more users is seen as better, even if those users are fake, trolls, or non-contributers.
After that a law of large numbers must've kicked in (and I don't think human nature had changed any much in last 3-4 decades).
It's comedy focused, but there's topical areas too. They remain one of the largest posting boards on the internet.
There's probably even a market right now for a paid version of reddit or HN.
The sad fact is that the internet has gradually become a shithole as the entirety of humanity has joined in.
Twitter, for example, is being dragged down by low quality user accounts that add nothing but noise. It's actively hurting the stock price.