News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:_why: A Tale Of A Post-Modern Genius by jimbokun on Saturday May 15, 2010 @11:58PM (#1351332)
"Bricklaying has been 'industrialized', and one day programming will be too."

This prediction has been made for decades now. I suppose if people keep predicting this indefinitely, someday it will become true.

In the meantime, new programming tasks are invented faster than the old tasks are industrialized.

"Once you get better at programming it is more like knitting or weaving than puzzling."

This is up to you. Was building Google, Amazon, Linux, Firefox, iPhone OS, etc. etc. etc. more like knitting or weaving than puzzling? Maybe what you are saying is that most programmers aren't good enough to build those kinds of products, or would just rather stick to their knitting and weaving. That I would agree with.

"Some programmers are better at this than others and can solve more complex problems."

This is trivially true of any cognitive task.

Re:_why: A Tale Of A Post-Modern Genius by jacquesm on Sunday May 16, 2010 @12:50AM (#1351403)
> This prediction has been made for decades now. I suppose if people keep predicting this indefinitely, someday it will become true.

One day is on purpose very vague, I haven't a clue on what timescale we're talking. But I'm fairly sure what will be the sign that we've reached it, it's when we will remove the term programming from language and use 'teaching' instead.

> This is up to you. Was building Google, Amazon, Linux, Firefox, iPhone OS, etc. etc. etc. more like knitting or weaving than puzzling? Maybe what you are saying is that most programmers aren't good enough to build those kinds of products, or would just rather stick to their knitting and weaving. That I would agree with.

Most of those were huge projects, but if you break them up in to little pieces some of them were artwork, most of them were bricks. The architecture of each of those was likely artwork.

> This is trivially true of any cognitive task.

Yes, but many programmers seem to think there is something 'magical' about the ability to program, as if there is some kind of essential element that differentiates those that can program from those that can not.

And I think that is not the case.

Re:_why: A Tale Of A Post-Modern Genius by Hexstream on Sunday May 16, 2010 @06:30PM (#1352943)
"many programmers seem to think there is something 'magical' about the ability to program, as if there is some kind of essential element that differentiates those that can program from those that can not."

You should read this, and maybe the linked academic paper, too: http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/2006/07/separating-programm...

Re:_why: A Tale Of A Post-Modern Genius by jacquesm on Sunday May 16, 2010 @06:57PM (#1352994)
I challenge you to find someone that I can't teach how to program a computer.

Maybe they won't be the next Donald Knuth, but they'll be able to hold down a job and make a living. I guarantee it.

You ship 'm I'll teach 'm, no matter how much time it takes I'll do it. The only pre-requirements are a willingness to learn and a willingness to spend the time, as well as an iq of 80 or more.

Anybody can do it, not equally fast, not equally good, some may hate it and some may love it.

That test is so biased it's not even funny, I've linked the script below, it assumes that people will clue in to the different meaning of the '=' sign in programming (assignment) as opposed to what it means in the rest of math (equality). I note that some programmers that are very well seasoned have been caught to mess up '==' and '='.

I always thought that the '=' sign for assignment was a huge mistake and that '<=' would have been far better.

But it's a little late for that now. What galls me even more about that test is that instead of providing a warm up with a bunch of assignment samples and 'print' statements afterwards would have given the really interested parties a shot at figuring out how it works, to test their assumptions.

The problem with programming is an educational one, not some kind of genetic pre-disposition to being able to program.

Just as there are people that are better and not-so-good at arithmetic there are people that are better and not-so-good at programming.

It's a skill thing, and if you work at it hard enough you can get better. The ten thousand hour rule definitely applies. If that's not the case then how come there are a thousand and one books that will teach you how to become a (better) programmer. It is teachable, it is a skill, there is no magic component, in spite of what this so-called study says.

Here is the test script:

http://www.eis.mdx.ac.uk/research/PhDArea/saeed/test(week-0)...

Have read, and see what you think, try to pretend that you have no programming knowledge and that all you know is arithmetic, it basically tests a single question in different forms over and over again.

In my opinion, a much better way to grade people to find out who will be the 'good' programmers is to find who is good at solving puzzles.

Re:_why: A Tale Of A Post-Modern Genius by jimbokun on Sunday May 16, 2010 @09:51PM (#1353248)
"The only pre-requirements are a willingness to learn and a willingness to spend the time..."

There are many people for who this is not true when it comes to programming, and this is why they will never become a programmer (good or otherwise).