News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:_why: A Tale Of A Post-Modern Genius by nostrademons on Saturday May 15, 2010 @11:20PM (#1351258)
Almost everything is not hard "in principle", though. In quantum physics, you've got 4 fundamental forces, a handful of elementary particles, and together they explain all of the universe. In medicine, you've got a bunch of organs hooked up to the circulatory/lymphatic/nervous systems, and they make the body go 'round. In molecular biology, you've got 4 bases of DNA and they explain basically everything.

The problem comes from the complex interactions between those elements. You can learn how the body works in high school biology, but that doesn't prepare you to operate on it. Similarly, you can learn how software is constructed ("make sure the right lines of code are used, follow each other, and are debugged properly") from Hacker News, but that doesn't prepare you to actually put those lines of code together.

One of the unfortunate effects of Internet forums is that it seems to have shifted attention from the nitty-gritty details of how to do something to the high-level overview of how to do something. So we have a bunch of programming forums where we talk about programming, but never actually program anything. It's not just programming (just look at reddit.com/r/economics), but programming seems to have been one of the most affected disciplines. But I'm afraid that this is giving a skewed perception of the field to newcomers, such that they look at the code they see on blogs or Hacker News and think that's all there is to programming. The #1 reason people fail Google interviews is because they don't have enough depth: they can recite code snippets they found on the web and maybe even put them together, but they can't analyze the performance of their programs or suggest how they might adapt them if requirements change.

Re:_why: A Tale Of A Post-Modern Genius by jacquesm on Saturday May 15, 2010 @11:32PM (#1351282)
Funny, yes, it really is like that, I call them 'cargo cult coders'.

Able to produce by tying together endless snippets of googled code, it is the professional equivalent of the script kiddie.