News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stallman Video: If You Want Freedom, Don’t Use Proprietar... by johnswamps on Saturday May 15, 2010 @10:57PM (#1351215)
But that's not what Stallman believes, that's what the author of the article wrote. What makes a freedom a freedom (to me) is that you have the ability to waive a freedom if you wish to do so -- otherwise it's an obligation. And Stallman is of the opinion that you should never trade freedom (at least when it comes to proprietary software) for convenience. I actually asked him about this a few weeks back, if he thought there were situations where it's reasonable to willingly and in full knowledge give up some freedom (the question was in the context of software as a service). He interrupted me before I finished and said that you should never do that, because even if you're not giving up much freedom now, they'll be taking more and more of it as times goes on. (I hope I'm not misrepresenting his views, but that is the impression I got.)

I disagree. While perhaps it's wrong that many people give up freedom without really knowing that they're doing so, I think it's reasonable to on occasion to do it if you know the trade-off you're making.

[deleted]
Re:Stallman Video: If You Want Freedom, Don’t Use Proprietar... by freetard on Saturday May 15, 2010 @11:22PM (#1351260)
Stallman usually talks about software when it comes to freedom. I wouldn't make any conclusions on his opinion about "freedom to kill" without asking him for clarification.
Re:Stallman Video: If You Want Freedom, Don’t Use Proprietar... by johnswamps on Saturday May 15, 2010 @11:30PM (#1351280)
Sorry, perhaps my post generalized too much. This was in the context of proprietary software, specifically software as a service. I've edited my post to clarify that.
Re:Stallman Video: If You Want Freedom, Don’t Use Proprietar... by Groxx on Saturday May 15, 2010 @11:34PM (#1351291)
I'll remove it, as it's mistaken. Sorry, internets!

Slippery slope == fallacy is still true though, and it's still a wholly invalid standpoint.