Executive orders can be illegal if they direct the executive branch to either do something illegal or if they direct the executive branch to fail to carry out their mandated duties. In that case the executive order may be challenged in court -- that is one of the things that is going to happen with this executive order. There will be cases flowing up the court system of people claiming this order is illegal, discriminatory, and violates the rights of legal residents.
Executive orders can also not be illegal, but may be taking advantage of flexibility that Congress regrets giving the executive branch. For instance, if the President begins selling off national parks, that may actually be within his authority, but it might inspire Congress to pass a law prohibiting him from doing so in the future.
As to how Trump is doing so many radical things so quickly, I would simply point out that he likely is not worrying about the consequences.
The President can issue executive orders very quickly if he chooses, but when most Presidents issue one creating a new, radical change (as opposed to the several dozen executive orders that get signed every time control of the White House passes between the two parties, like the Mexico City Rule), he first will spend a lot of time working with the affected departments and with his own lawyers to figure out exactly what he has the authority to do. For instance, before Obama introduced DACA, he first had to spend a lot of time figuring out exactly how much of the DREAM act he could get away with implementing purely with his executive power -- he didn't want to take the action and immediately have it reversed by the courts.
Now, if you don't worry about what you can and can't do and just do it, everything moves a lot faster. You might say Trump is governing the Facebook way: Move Fast and Break Things.
So I think the legal footing that Trump is trying to make is with respect to 'security'.
And it's temporary.
So those two things: that's it's for 'national security' and 'temporary' may make this within his power.
After 9/11 - Bush did a somewhat similar thing - changed the entry rules temporarily while new legislation/processes was enacted.
It's going to be a long 4 years, we need to saver our energy for the right fights.
I'll bet $1000 that after 90 days, the system will remain de-facto the same as it was before.
The 'long term' fight that is really relevant to 'us nerds' I think will be net-neutrality.
That will be permanent.
But the immigration action certainly has graver immediate and acute effects.
And, in any case, it's not a choice of fight this or fight that.
That said, I feel the same way. I'm not an Obama supporter, but I gotta wonder why he wasn't even more aggressive than he was with the orders.
Republicons constantly accused Obama of signing too many "unconstitutional" executive orders.
In terms of substantive, direct, responses (e.g., excluding retaliating against other Presidential initiatives and appointments), major notable options include:
(1) Expressly prohibit the things called for in the order by legislation (overriding a veto, of necessary);
(2) Sue the administration claiming the order violates existing (statute or Constitutional) law;
(3) Impeach and remove the President.
Looking in from the outside, it seems like all the political process that Obama had to go through just isn't applicable?
The example I always comforted myself with w.r.t to Trump was Obama trying to get the gun laws changed - even the POTUS couldn't do it. So then he mustn't have unlimited power. So what's going on here?
I'm really curious how executive orders work in the US. Are they just the first step in a process, or do they override any democratic process? The latter seems to be what all the reporting is implying, but I don't know if that's hyperbole or true.