News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Five-month-old babies know what’s funny by derefr on Friday January 27, 2017 @05:30PM (#13503322)
Jokes have to be targeted at the audience's intelligence level, certainly. Watch a "comedic" children's cartoon, and you'll find many jokes which fall flat because you can see them coming.

In such situations, it's not really that you fully knew what was going to happen the whole time, mind you; it's just that you got to the conclusion faster than the joke itself did, and then your anticipational sense died down as you waited for the delivery to "catch up."

People say that comedy is all about timing. Essentially, that consists of telling someone about a pattern (or signalling to them that you're aware of said pattern), at exactly the moment they themselves also deduce that pattern. If you do it too soon, you get simple confusion; if you do it too late, you get a half-smirk of resigned acceptance.

But (adult) humans fall mostly into a pretty narrow band as far as prediction goes; and that band gets even narrower when the prediction is of social situations, since our social-tribal predictions are more "hardware accelerated" by genetically-specified bits of brain matter, and less the result of learned arbitrary pattern-recognition. So there are certain topics of comedy for which the timing is very close to universal, regardless of a person's IQ.

On the other hand, if you were to take IQ test questions (or "brainteaser" puzzles generally) and incorporate them into a visual narrative (e.g. a movie) where the protagonist goes about solving said problems as the audience watches--and then you showed this movie to people--I would expect you to see a reaction very much like that of people to a comedy sketch, but only, in each case, for the particular puzzles where the audience-member subconsciously solved the puzzle at exactly the same moment the movie's protagonist did. The rest would fall flat.

(This could actually be tested fairly easily: there are a lot of blind Let's Play videos of puzzle-platformer games that could be used as apparatus.)

There are no comments on this comment yet.