Re:As Facebook Takes a Beating, a Brutal Movie Is Set to Mak...
by philwelch on Saturday May 15, 2010 @11:24PM
(#1351263)
One thing that annoys me is internet comment threads speculating about the mental health of people the commenters have most likely never even met.
Re:As Facebook Takes a Beating, a Brutal Movie Is Set to Mak...
by zeemonkee on Sunday May 16, 2010 @11:18AM
(#1352142)
There was a psychiatrist that was hired by the US govt in WW2 to analyse Hitler.
Despite never having met him, and not being a military man, the psychiatrist (I forget his name) predicted Hitler's strategy for the rest of the war - and the eventual suicide, having brought Germany to ruin.
So it's not always necessary for an analyst - a good one that is, not an armchair amateur - to have met their subject in order to perform a successful analysis.
Re:As Facebook Takes a Beating, a Brutal Movie Is Set to Mak...
by philwelch on Sunday May 16, 2010 @08:15PM
(#1353112)
I had no idea the state of psychiatry in the 1940's was good enough to, for instance, predict a leader's strategies. I'd love to read more about this.
Re:As Facebook Takes a Beating, a Brutal Movie Is Set to Mak...
by inboulder on Saturday May 15, 2010 @01:48PM
(#1350295)
Not that I disagree, but "inability to respect social norms" is basically part of the definition of Borderline Personality disorder or Narcissism, so saying as much is basically tautological.
Re:As Facebook Takes a Beating, a Brutal Movie Is Set to Mak...
by barrkel on Saturday May 15, 2010 @02:50PM
(#1350418)
Basically that's what he was saying: that Aspergers or borderline autistic are basically less accurate descriptions than BPD etc.
Re:As Facebook Takes a Beating, a Brutal Movie Is Set to Mak...
by neurotech1 on Saturday May 15, 2010 @05:06PM
(#1350658)
The "inability to respect social norms" is more an issue for the therapist than their supposedly Asperger's patients.
Borderline Personality disorder or Narcissism would be closer to the mark.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Borderline_personality_disorder http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Narcissism
When I worked around more therapists(I worked as a qEEG tech) it became apparent that some are the worst offenders when it comes to "inability to respect social norms"