News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Libor: the bankers who fixed the world’s most important n... by SilasX on Friday January 27, 2017 @12:51PM (#13501297)
That's a good point, but I don't think it fully addresses what that parent was saying, which is that Libor isn't a price, but a subjective assessment. So it would be more like if two gas stations agreed to use the same marketing language to promote their stores [1] -- yes, it's collusion, but over a signal they never represented as an objective benchmark, even though people started using it as one.

[1] "we'll both say we have 'fresh produce', and one month out of the year we'll both say it's 'very fresh produce'"

Re:Libor: the bankers who fixed the world’s most important n... by AnimalMuppet on Friday January 27, 2017 @01:26PM (#13501510)
Libor is in fact a price - the price of renting money. There are actual loans and/or bonds made at Libor (often plus an offset).
Re:Libor: the bankers who fixed the world’s most important n... by hermitdev on Friday January 27, 2017 @01:44PM (#13501630)
Indeed. I worked at a hedge fund that also traded bank debt. One of the loans we owned while I was there was offered at Libor + ~18% (yes, percent, not basis points), and the notional was a half billion pounds. The daily accrued interest on that loan paid my yearly salary twice over. This loan was also held in the same era that the article is regarding. The US dollar vs pound exchange rate was extremely volatile in that same period. That period resulted in lots of late night phone calls regarding wild PnL swings and what happened and why. I had never really paid much attention to FX rates until that period. But, when the daily question is why are we missing X millions of dollars, and the answer was due to a fall of the dollar vs the pound, I had to start paying attention. That year or so was the worst year of my professional life.
Re:Libor: the bankers who fixed the world’s most important n... by SilasX on Friday January 27, 2017 @01:36PM (#13501573)
The point is that there is a subtlety -- the difference between a price, and a signal that other people use to set prices. Libor is the latter. Colluding on a signal is not the same as colluding on the prices themselves, the argument goes.
Re:Libor: the bankers who fixed the world’s most important n... by hermitdev on Friday January 27, 2017 @01:45PM (#13501644)
A lot of large loans are set to Libor plus an offset. You might think it is a signal, but is, in a very real sense, also a price.
Re:Libor: the bankers who fixed the world’s most important n... by AnimalMuppet on Friday January 27, 2017 @02:43PM (#13502039)
Well... SilasX has at least half a point. If the Libor rate is being messed with (and if the messing nets to a Libor that is a consistent, say, 0.05% too low), people making contracts could adjust the offset up by 0.05%.

But I still think that SilasX's view isn't the right way to look at this. Why were people messing with Libor? It wasn't because they were going to make more money off of interbank loans. It's because they were going to make more money off of other things that were keyed to Libor. So, yes, they were using Libor to manipulate the price of things.

And if I understand correctly, it works like this: The contract says Libor + X%. The X is fixed at the time the contract is negotiated, not at the time it closes. Then, later, the contract closes, and uses the Libor at the date of closing. This means that the Libor-setters move last, after the offset is determined. This makes it impossible in practice to use the offset to fix the Libor machinations.

Re:Libor: the bankers who fixed the world’s most important n... by hermitdev on Friday January 27, 2017 @03:37PM (#13502437)
Agreed, in that every loan I ever saw had a fixed Libor offset. Disagree, in that Libor was fixed at closing, instead it was most often used as a floating rate. So, you had a floating Libor + a fixed offset. In regards to manipulating Libor to move downwards would have only hurt the bottom line of my firm.