Don't people have anything else to do?
Large, complex systems are by there very nature difficult to understand. Being able to summarize them easily — even if they don't completely capture the nuance — allows people to get an idea of what's going on. It's not much different from using KPIs and other metrics to understand a business.
You can argue that the metrics aren't useful, but providing reasons why you think so, and possibly suggest better ways would help justify your claim.
For example, let's made up some criteria:
1 minute = 99% probability of human extinction in 10 years
2 minutes = 98% probability of human extinction in 10 years
3 minutes = 97% probability of human extinction in 10 years
I'm not sure what 2 hours means. Probably the scale should not be more complex than (100-p) * min/%
Or perhaps it's better to define 1 minute = 90% probability of human extinction in 100 years
Or 1 minute = 50% probability of human extinction in 1 year
It's not clear what 1 minute before doomsday officially means.
Moreover, let's say that they define that 1 minute is x% chance of humanity destruction in y years. How are they calculating it? Do they have any model? How did they calibrate the model? How did they test the model? Is it reliable?
It's a made up number, without any scientific base. It's only an opinion of a bunch of people that happened to work as scientific, not a scientific measurement.
You have to start somewhere, and having a group of people who specifically decide to take into account what they consider useful criteria and deliberate about it is a step forward. I think it's clear it could be better if it were more rigorous. It wouldn't surprise me if there are people out there working to do just that. It's not useless just because it's attempting to quantify a complex system in a more subjective manner when it's not clear better alternatives are available. You're right that it's an opinion of scientists, and not a scientific measurement. They're experts in their fields and their opinion does mean something. You're free to weight that how you want, of course.
Scientifics say the Doomsday clock is 2:30 minutes before Midnight
Scientifics say this wall painting is 40.000 years old
Which one is reliable? Which one should a young Earth creationist believe? Are 40.000 years real years or some kind of metaphor? Is that number reliable?I'm not sure what you're arguing so strongly against. I'm not saying the Doomsday Clock is perfect. I think it's useful. It can likely be improved. When/if we can find better quantitative representation for this, I agree we should use it.
Don't fixate on the "imaginary clock" aspect, it's just a representation.
Otherwise they should have used something more appropriate to make their point.
No quarrel with their directional moves ... now or at any other time. But they've ended up in the incongruous situation of saying that 2017 at this very moment is already more risky than the Cuban missile crisis of 1962, or Barry Goldwater's mutterings about nuclear options in Vietnam in 1964, or the China-Russia border war of 1969.
No. Simply no. They missed the chance in the early 1990s to move the clock back to about 3 p.m., giving themselves much more room to create carefully graduated increments of alarm as fresh stresses arose. The current state of play in the USA deserves much more than a 30-second adjustment, and somewhat less than a declaration that it's 2 1/2 minutes before midnight. I can think of at least a dozen ways things could get worse before we're at imminent risk of breathing radioactive isotopes for the (annoyingly short) rest of our lives. Some of those perils already popped up in the 1950s/1960s, and we made our way through them.
The current clock settings hardly do justice to the scientific method, or the rightful role of subject experts in public debate.