I had expected Google to sell the phone over the web for $99 with no contract. That would have been the sort of bold, gutsy move that Google needs to do to change the mobile phone market.
It seems that Google is actually looking to get a piece of the existing pie and doesn't care about changing the way phones are sold.
The Nexus One is cheaper than a contract free (but still locked!) iPhone 3GS. Their "mistake" was being honest about the price, and not explaining how it would more than pay for itself in lower monthly charges if you used T-Mobile's non-contract rates. Even that may not have worked, because consumers are generally really bad at math.
I think Google's pricing was targeted at investors (as in look, we can get top dollar for a phone just like Apple) rather than at consumers who would happily give Google lots of behavioral data for ads in exchange for a discounted phone.
Unsubsidized HTC Desire from local brick and mortar store = 400 EUR.
So I guess that the opinion 'Google drastically overpriced the phone.' is still valid.
Although, I did see a lot of Google Ads for the Nexus One.
I'm actually surprised that it didn't work. This was top premium ad space. How can it fail? Unless their expectations for sales were so stratospheric that even their massive campaign couldn't pull it off?