News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by alain94040 on Friday May 14, 2010 @01:47PM (#1348000)
Amazing failure, when you consider that they advertised the Nexus One on the #1 most prominent web page possible: the google search form.

I'm actually surprised that it didn't work. This was top premium ad space. How can it fail? Unless their expectations for sales were so stratospheric that even their massive campaign couldn't pull it off?

Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by jrockway on Friday May 14, 2010 @02:20PM (#1348094)
People don't like multi-year multi-thousand-dollar commitments, even if they see an ad on Google.
Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by grandalf on Friday May 14, 2010 @04:07PM (#1348436)
Correct. Google drastically overpriced the phone. As others have pointed out, signing up for a multi year contract in exchange isn't really a bad deal unless you wanted out of the contract sooner (and even then it's not too bad).

I had expected Google to sell the phone over the web for $99 with no contract. That would have been the sort of bold, gutsy move that Google needs to do to change the mobile phone market.

It seems that Google is actually looking to get a piece of the existing pie and doesn't care about changing the way phones are sold.

Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by orangecat on Friday May 14, 2010 @06:28PM (#1348812)
Google drastically overpriced the phone.

The Nexus One is cheaper than a contract free (but still locked!) iPhone 3GS. Their "mistake" was being honest about the price, and not explaining how it would more than pay for itself in lower monthly charges if you used T-Mobile's non-contract rates. Even that may not have worked, because consumers are generally really bad at math.

Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by grandalf on Friday May 14, 2010 @08:43PM (#1349049)
Perhaps. But just as Google offers gmail for free I think it would have been possible to design a business model that allowed the phone to be sold at a discount without a contract.

I think Google's pricing was targeted at investors (as in look, we can get top dollar for a phone just like Apple) rather than at consumers who would happily give Google lots of behavioral data for ads in exchange for a discounted phone.

Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by vetinari on Saturday May 15, 2010 @12:29AM (#1349348)
Unsubsidized Nexus One from Google = 600 EUR.

Unsubsidized HTC Desire from local brick and mortar store = 400 EUR.

So I guess that the opinion 'Google drastically overpriced the phone.' is still valid.

Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by eli on Sunday May 16, 2010 @01:10AM (#1351435)
Really Google suffered from not putting an end to those ridiculous $99 phone pre-launch rumors. It was not reasonable to expect them to sell a phone at a huge loss per device just to expand the reach of their platform.
Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by danudey on Friday May 14, 2010 @04:47PM (#1348548)
They don't like having to pay two separate early termination fees either, oddly enough.
Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by ippisl on Saturday May 15, 2010 @08:45AM (#1349794)
Maybe the N1 was just an experiment for google , to learn about the mobile phone market,and to be ready in the time when unsubsidized phones are available in a reasonable price.
Re:Google admitting defeat in 'direct to consumer' model pho... by billpaetzke on Friday May 14, 2010 @04:16PM (#1348471)
Who searches from google.com anymore? Searching from in-browser is so much faster/efficient.

Although, I did see a lot of Google Ads for the Nexus One.