As far as I know, only T-Mobile USA has really come on board so far to make non-subsidized phones a better deal. T-Mobile has cheaper rates if you are not on contract. If you buy the AT&T compatible Nexus One, for example, you still pay the phone "subsidy" the entire time are using AT&T, even though you own the phone outright.
Can we expect LTE phones to work across carriers? If so, I anticipate a demand for change in the US when someone brings their out-of-contract ATT phone over to Verizon and realize they are paying as much as someone that got a subsidy.
When the N1 came out, however, people were for some reason surprised about this. There's lots of news about it: http://www.google.com/search?q=t-mobile+%22nexus+one%22+%22n...
Google seems to think the former case deserves to pay $100 more for the phone.
Otherwise, you have people entering (comical) 20 year contracts, which would be (practically) unenforceable.
Given that the average Indian worker makes less than $6k a year, I'm not sure I'd really describe those figures as a "sweet spot".
The market for smart phones is pretty big in India.
(Don't have the sales numbers at hand. But Admob metrics report shows that in the first 3 months of 2010, they served 2.8 billion requests to cellphones in India. 63.1% of them were from smart phones. This doesn't mean that 2 out of 3 cell phones in India are smart phones as folks without smart phones don't usually go online much. But it does mean that the Indian market for smart phones is bigger than the Australian market - where Admob served 656 million requests in the first quarter of 2010.)
India has unequal distribution of wealth compared to western countries. Thinking of India as a poor country is common mistake.
If you don't mind me asking, how/why do you use two phones?
And, if you got a lemon, you couldn't take it back and exchange it for a new model (you had to wait weeks while it was repaired by HTC (assuming N1 here)).
I really don't understand why people keep missing these two crucial points, which TRUMP ALL OTHERS.
There are bigger, more mature markets elsewhere. Go after them. You might even get more people to use your services (maps, etc.) on a mobile than they would on a PC.
Also, $350-$400 (may be even $500 for topend) is a sweet spot for smart phones in India. And people do buy these phones in open market without a contract.
All the best. Go forth and prosper.
/an iPhone and Droid owner.