A quiet title action and partition by sale is not a "legal hack." A quiet title action is a structured process for unifying title while compensating people with ownership interests. And because a single clear title in a property is much more valuable than a bunch of possessory interests in the same property (even put together), partition by sale maximizes the value of the land. So each person's share of the auction proceeds will be more than the market value of their original possessory interests.
None of this is indicative of anything being "broken." It's basically unavoidable so long as fractional interests in land and subdivision of interests on inheritance are permitted.
But as I said, I know only what I've learned via today's jetlag + modafinil fueled googling session.
But brother A can still sell his interest in the land. Whoever buys it steps into brother A's shoes--they're joint tenants with brother B (or his descendants). That's basically what Zuckerberg did. And as a joint tenant, he can seek a partition, which basically tells the court "hey, I don't want to share possession of this land, auction it and cash out everyone's interest."
Such a need for strict definition of ownership (beyond any natural meaning) is the actual colonialism as felt by the indigenous
Without passing judgement on pros or cons; if someone from a foreign land xomes to you and insists that you adopt their ways of dealing with ownership and abandon your own, that is colonialism.
Rephrasing GP with emphasis:
> Such a need for strict definition of ownership (beyond any natural meaning) is the actual colonialism as felt by the indigenous
The same type of colonization is happening to our information environment via the imposition of "imaginary property".
You mean in terms of airspace? Because that's a thing but it ends at space, which nobody owns. It's a system that works pretty well.
But airspace is a good example too of something that has not been formally divided up with property rights. We would only say that USG "owns" the airspace as a way of understanding within the malapplied framework - it doesn't accurately describe the situation on its own merits.
(And FWIW this non-ownership is starting to show its cracks with the advent of high density batteries and cheap brushless motor controllers ("drones"). This situation in Hawaii seems like the equivalent of an airport suing to gain exclusive title over all airspace it currently mediates, trampling over all the rest of the existing airspace users)
Please see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_land https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enclosure
This whole situation also reminds me a bit of the Vogons destroying earth:
"There’s no point in acting surprised about it. All the planning charts and demolition orders have been on display at your local planning department in Alpha Centauri for 50 of your Earth years, so you’ve had plenty of time to lodge any formal complaint and it’s far too late to start making a fuss about it now. ... What do you mean you’ve never been to Alpha Centauri? Oh, for heaven’s sake, mankind, it’s only four light years away, you know. I’m sorry, but if you can’t be bothered to take an interest in local affairs, that’s your own lookout. Energize the demolition beams."
This is private land owned by a large number of people (many of who might not even realize it).
Creditors are hesitant to deal with any questionable land until title has been quieted by this process so they know the purchaser has full ownership and there can be no further disputes. The quiet title process is a request for all those with interest in the land to speak up and resolve the situation.
This prevents, for example, handing out a construction mortgage for someone to build a home on the land and then realizing three years later that your collateral is in jeopardy because several entities have decided to dispute the mortgagee's right to that land after the home was built.
In reality the law is not a programming language, and trying to treat it as such is a common cause of disappointment, frustration, anger, needless bickering, extended conflict, and vexatiously long and mostly unenforceable contracts.
My ex went to law school, and I found the attitude of "non-lawyers have no business having opinions about the law" that her law school promoted to be vile. That said, I've found that it's a good idea to assume that any legal issue is NOT straightforward. Doing otherwise usually ends up making me look ignorant, and has me spreading false conclusions to other non-lawyers around me.
The value doesn't have to be equal, simply that both sides offer something of value: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consideration#Monetary_value_o...
After going through an extremely nasty contract dispute I learned that contracts have limited value and that I should never trust anyone, even if 4 lawyers reviewed the terms.
There's a large cohort of smart people who've read a program and think this means they grasp its semantics; but without understanding the language specification, compiler bugs, undefined behavior implementation, posix specification, operating system bugs and configuration of deployment environment.
Much like programming languages, law language has evolved to be written in a way that's unambiguous as possible. Like programming languages, contracts and the like don't succeed in having 100% predictable semantics.
One source of unpredictability of results comes from the lack of a stable, 100% predictable execution platform (namely, judges, juries, lawyers, and current case law and legislation), much like compilers and platforms do not 100% specify their behavior, or even when they do, the run-time behavior is not perfectly predictable (e.g. when does the GC run).
Another source of unpredictability is that law at the end of the day must interface with the non-legal world ('facts' vs. law) and so touches global context which isn't known when the law or contract was drafted, which one might compare to dealing with unforeseen interactions with the OS, deployment environments, user input, etc.
So while laws and programs try to accurately and precisely encode their own internal semantics, they sometimes fail because they depend on other things that don't have perfectly defined semantics.
If they are owned by rich people, maybe that's not a bad thing. Maybe it's a way to spread their wealth to the lesser fortunate. Heh.
Areas without a clear title tend to be poor because as soon as someone tries to build a factory, workshop, business, or even just a nice house they're hit with multiple lawsuits.
Development isn't an unambiguous good. It's very possible the owners are happier with possession of family land over whatever sum of money they could get.
The wikipedia article on quiet title is also clarifying: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quiet_title
So is this article on quiet title: http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/who-can-claim-propert...
If I understand it right, the issue here is situations like the following. You've got a parcel of land which was 1/2 owned by brother A and 1/2 owned by brother B (due to, e.g., inheritance). Brother A occupied the parcel for 20+ years and eventually sold it to someone else. At this point, according to Hawaii's adverse posession law, brother A owns it but owes compensation to brother B. Now many years later, brother A or his descendents sold to Zuckerberg (or some similar chain of title), and brother B's descendents may not even know they had some right to the land.
There's a theoretical possibility that some descendent of brother B may show up and claim the land.
These quiet title lawsuits are a way for Zuckerberg to pre-emptively settle all such issues. It's also apparently a very common and accepted way to handle such issues in Hawaii.
This is basically just a horrible legal hack around the fact that Hawaii (like many places) has a totally broken title registration system. Without this hack it might be difficult/impossible for a land owner to know with any certainty that they actually own the land they just purchased.
If someone knows more about this, or if my understanding is incorrect, please correct me. I know little beyond what I learned via google.